Mercedes-Benz Political Audit

Executive Summary

This report constitutes a comprehensive governance and political risk audit of Mercedes-Benz Group AG (MBG), executed with the specific objective of determining the entity’s political complicity regarding the State of Israel, the occupation of Palestinian territories, and the ongoing conflict in Gaza. The audit applies a rigorous “Safe Harbor” methodology to contrast the corporation’s geopolitical maneuvering in the European theater against its operations in the Levant.

The investigation reveals a deep, structural integration between Mercedes-Benz Group AG and the Israeli security and economic apparatus. This complicity is not merely incidental but is institutionalized through governance ideologies rooted in “historical responsibility,” direct material supply of critical military logistics (tank transporters and armored medical units), and strategic technological partnerships with the Israeli defense-innovation ecosystem.

While the corporation executed a rapid and total divestment from the Russian Federation following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine—citing violations of international law and a “war of aggression”—its response to the 2023-2024 conflict in Gaza has been characterized by expedited military supply, financial contributions to Israeli emergency services, and the deepening of Research and Development (R&D) ties.

1. Governance Ideology and Executive Alignment

The governance ideology of Mercedes-Benz Group AG is heavily influenced by the German socio-political framework of Staatsräson (reason of state), which regards the security of Israel as a non-negotiable tenet of German foreign and corporate policy. This ideological baseline permeates the Board of Management and the Supervisory Board, creating a corporate culture where support for Israeli state infrastructure is viewed as an ethical imperative rather than a political choice.

1.1 The “Historical Responsibility” Doctrine

The executive leadership, led by Chairman of the Board of Management Ola Källenius, consistently frames the company’s alignment with Israel through the lens of German history. Following the events of October 7, 2023, Källenius did not issue a neutral statement calling for de-escalation. Instead, he utilized his professional platforms to express that he was “deeply shaken” by the attacks, explicitly centering the narrative on the victimization of the Israeli state and the safety of the company’s Tel Aviv-based workforce.¹

This stance was formalized through collective corporate action. Mercedes-Benz was a signatory to the “Never Again is Now” campaign, a full-page manifesto published in major German newspapers signed by 106 top corporations.² The text of the advertisement condemned “Hamas terror” and pledged solidarity with Israel, explicitly linking corporate citizenship to the protection of the Jewish state. While ostensibly a stance against antisemitism, in the context of the ensuing bombardment of Gaza, this alignment functioned as a corporate endorsement of the Israeli state’s casus belli, effectively shielding the company’s subsequent military supply chain activities from internal ethical scrutiny.

1.2 Board Composition and Transatlantic Networks

The ideological orientation of the board is reinforced by memberships in elite policy networks that advocate for strong transatlantic and German-Israeli ties.

• Ola Källenius (Chairman): Källenius has been a recipient of awards from the American Chamber of Commerce (AmCham), a network deeply embedded in the US-German-Israeli trilateral trade relationship. His leadership has overseen the “Ambition 2039” strategy, but his geopolitical positioning remains firmly anchored in Western security alliances.³
• Renata Jungo Brüngger (Integrity & Legal Affairs): As the board member responsible for Human Rights and Integrity, Jungo Brüngger occupies a critical node in the complicity matrix. Her department oversees the implementation of the German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (LkSG). However, the audit finds no evidence that her office has triggered human rights risk assessments regarding the use of Mercedes-Benz Arocs tank transporters in Gaza, despite the clear “high risk” designation of the conflict zone. Her background involves significant engagement with foundations and civil society, yet the “integrity” mechanisms appear to selectively bypass the Palestinian context.⁵
• Atlantik-Brücke Alignment: Several high-ranking German corporate figures move within the orbit of the Atlantik-Brücke (Atlantic Bridge), a non-profit association promoting German-American friendship. While the specific membership of current Mercedes board members in this private organization is often shielded, the corporate network overlaps significantly. The alignment of Mercedes-Benz’s geopolitical strategy with the Atlanticist worldview—which staunchly supports Israeli security—suggests an ideological synchronization with these elite policy councils.⁷

1.3 Shareholder Structure: The Geopolitical Paradox

The ownership structure of Mercedes-Benz Group AG presents a complex geopolitical paradox involving Arab sovereign wealth and German industrial interests.

The Kuwait Investment Authority (KIA) has held a stake in Mercedes-Benz (formerly Daimler) since 1974. This long-standing partnership is celebrated by Kuwaiti officials as a model of “trust, sustainability, and innovation”.⁹ However, this financial relationship survives in tension with Kuwait’s domestic foreign policy, which strictly forbids normalization with Israel. The audit identifies this as a critical “Disconnect Risk”: the profits accruing to the Kuwaiti state are partially derived from the sale of military vehicles used in the occupation of Palestine. To date, there is no evidence of the KIA using its shareholder voting rights to censure Mercedes-Benz for its expedited military deliveries to the IDF.

2. The “Safe Harbor” Test: Comparative Geopolitics

The “Safe Harbor” test evaluates the consistency of a corporation’s ethical and operational responses to similar geopolitical crises. A comparison of Mercedes-Benz’s actions regarding the Russia-Ukraine war (2022) versus the Israel-Gaza war (2023-2024) reveals a definitive double standard, termed here as the “Geopolitical Alignment Bias.”

2.1 The Ukraine Benchmark: “War of Aggression”

Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Mercedes-Benz mobilized its corporate machinery to sever ties with the aggressor state.

• Rhetoric: Corporate communications adopted the language of international law, referring to the conflict as a “war of aggression” and a “brutal war” initiated by Russia.¹⁰
• Operational Cessation: The company suspended the export of passenger cars and vans to Russia and halted local manufacturing “until further notice” almost immediately.¹²
• Divestment: By October 2022, the Group announced a complete withdrawal from the Russian market, selling its shares in Russian subsidiaries to local investor Avtodom. This involved accepting significant financial write-offs and the loss of a major luxury market.¹³

2.2 The Gaza Reality: Expedited Support

In stark contrast, the company’s response to the Israeli military campaign in Gaza—characterized by international courts and bodies as plausibly genocidal—was one of reinforced support.

• Rhetoric: Statements focused exclusively on “terrorist attacks against Israel” and “suffering of civilians,” actively avoiding any attribution of responsibility to the Israeli military for infrastructure destruction in Gaza.¹
• Operational Acceleration: Rather than suspending exports, the company expedited the delivery of military logistics vehicles. In November 2023, amidst the height of the bombardment, 112 Arocs heavy-duty tank transporters were delivered to the IDF.¹⁶
• Financial Injection: While divesting from Russia, Mercedes-Benz injected €1 million into United Hatzalah, an Israeli emergency organization that operates in close coordination with the IDF and national security apparatus during wartime.¹⁵

2.3 Comparative Analysis Table

3. Operational Complicity: The Military Logistics Backbone

The material support provided by Mercedes-Benz to the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is not limited to commercial off-the-shelf vehicles but involves specialized heavy logistics platforms that function as the backbone of the ground invasion.

3.1 The Arocs Tank Transporter: Moving the Iron

The specific nature of the 112 Arocs heavy-duty tractor heads delivered in November 2023 renders them “Mission Critical” assets.

• Function: These trucks are engineered to haul extreme loads, specifically the Merkava Mark 4 main battle tank, which weighs approximately 65 tons.
• Operational Context: The ability to rapidly redeploy armor between the Gaza envelope and the Northern front (Lebanon border) is a strategic prerequisite for the IDF’s multi-front war doctrine. The Mercedes Arocs trucks provided the mobility solution for this redeployment during the active invasion phases of late 2023.¹⁶
• Tender History: This expedited delivery was part of a broader tender won in 2022 for 460 units, replacing American-made trucks that the IDF found unsatisfactory. This explicitly identifies Mercedes-Benz as the preferred supplier for heavy military logistics.²⁰

3.2 The Sprinter Ambulance and FMF Funding Cycles

The delivery of 30 Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 4×4 ambulances in November 2023 highlights a sophisticated tripartite procurement mechanism involving the US government, the Israeli Ministry of Defense (IMOD), and Mercedes-Benz manufacturing.

• The US Connection: These specific Sprinters were manufactured in the United States (likely at the Charleston, SC plant).²¹
• Funding Mechanism: Because they are US-made, these vehicles are eligible for purchase using Foreign Military Financing (FMF) aid. This allows Israel to buy Mercedes vehicles using US taxpayer money granted as military aid.²⁰
• Militarization: Once delivered, these vehicles are armored by Plasan Re’em, an Israeli defense contractor. This partnership transforms a civilian van into a “bullet-proof” armored medical transport used in combat zones.²⁴ The collaboration between Mercedes (chassis) and Plasan (armor) creates a final product that is a dedicated instrument of war.

3.3 The Unimog and G-Class: Tactical Mobility

The Mercedes-Benz Unimog and G-Class (G-Wagon) serve as the tactical mobility layer for the IDF.

• Unimog U5000: Used for troop transport and as a platform for mounted weapons systems. The modular nature of the Unimog allows for the integration of Israeli-made command and control systems.²⁶
• G-Class (Series 464): Marketed for “Rescue and Special Operations,” these vehicles feature an “Emergency Override System.” They are used by border patrol and special forces units for operations in the West Bank and Gaza peripheries.²⁸

4. Technological Integration, Surveillance, and R&D

Mercedes-Benz’s Tel Aviv Research and Development Center serves as a strategic node for integrating Israeli military-grade technology into the global automotive fleet. This center is not an isolated outpost but a bridge between the German automotive giant and the Israeli “Silicon Wadi,” which is deeply intertwined with the security state.

4.1 The Unit 8200 Pipeline

The R&D center, established in 2017, focuses on “Car IT and Security.” In the Israeli context, expertise in cybersecurity is almost exclusively generated within the military, specifically Unit 8200 (signals intelligence).

• Recruitment: While Mercedes-Benz does not publish the service records of its staff, the center’s focus on cyber-defense and data encryption necessitates recruiting from the pool of Unit 8200 alumni. This creates a talent pipeline where skills honed in military surveillance and cyber-offensive operations are transferred to the corporate entity.³⁰
• Dual-Use Technology: The technologies developed—V2X (Vehicle-to-Everything) communication, autonomous navigation, and fleet management—are classic dual-use technologies. Fleet management software developed for commercial logistics is functionally similar to command-and-control systems used for military convoys.³²

4.2 Strategic Partnerships with the Defense Ecosystem

Mercedes-Benz has actively partnered with entities that have deep roots in the Israeli defense sector.

• Via Transportation: A partnership to develop ride-sharing algorithms. Via was founded by graduates of the Talpiot program, the IDF’s elite academic-technology training track. This partnership validates and monetizes technology developed through military training programs.³³
• Gauzy: A partnership involving smart glass technology, which also produces ADAS (Advanced Driver Assistance Systems). Gauzy is a Nasdaq-listed entity that exemplifies the civilian-military fusion of the Israeli tech sector.³⁴
• Israel Innovation Authority (IIA): Mercedes-Benz maintains a formal cooperation agreement with the IIA (government entity) to scout for technologies. This agreement effectively subsidizes the company’s R&D by leveraging Israeli state funding to identify startups, further embedding the company in the national economy.³⁵

5. Lobbying, Trade, and “Brand Israel” Diplomacy

Beyond material supply, Mercedes-Benz engages in “soft power” support for Israel through lobbying, trade chamber memberships, and the sponsorship of events that normalize the Israeli economy and technology sector.

5.1 Innovation Diplomacy: EcoMotion and DLD

The company uses high-profile technology conferences to cement its status as a key stakeholder in the Israeli economy.

• EcoMotion: Mercedes-Benz has been a consistent partner (e.g., Silver Partner in 2023) of EcoMotion, a smart mobility community supported by the Israeli government. Participation in this event is a form of “Brand Israel” endorsement, validating the sector internationally.³⁷
• DLD Tel Aviv: The company has sponsored the DLD Tel Aviv Innovation Festival, with executives like Eyal Mayer (Head of Innovation, Tel Aviv) serving as judges for startup competitions. This active participation promotes the narrative of Israel as a “Startup Nation,” diverting attention from the occupation economy.³⁹

5.2 German-Israeli Institutional Ties

The company is a pillar of the German-Israeli Chamber of Industry & Commerce (AHK Israel), which facilitates bilateral trade. Through this body, Mercedes-Benz lobbies for favorable trade conditions that benefit its exports to Israel.⁴¹ Furthermore, the company engages with cultural institutions like the German-Israeli Future Forum, sponsoring employee exchange programs that foster ideological alignment between the German and Israeli workforces under the guise of “diversity” training.⁴²

6. Internal Policy, Labor, and the “Neutrality” Trap

Internal governance at Mercedes-Benz is characterized by a rigorous enforcement of ideological conformity regarding Israel, often framed as anti-discrimination policy.

6.1 The IHRA Definition as Corporate Law

By adopting the IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism ⁴³, Mercedes-Benz has effectively codified a policy that can conflate anti-Zionism with antisemitism. In the German corporate context, this definition is often used to silence Palestinian solidarity by framing it as hate speech. This creates a “chilling effect” where employees are deterred from voicing opposition to the company’s supply of military vehicles to Israel for fear of disciplinary action or reputational damage.

6.2 Labor Suppression: A Transatlantic Pattern

While specific internal memos regarding Palestine solidarity at Mercedes-Benz have not been leaked in the provided intelligence, the company’s labor practices in the United States suggest a willingness to suppress worker activism.

• Union Busting in Alabama: The company is currently under investigation by the German government for violating the LkSG due to aggressive union-busting tactics at its Vance, Alabama plant. This includes the firing of union organizers.⁴⁵
• Implication: This demonstrates that Mercedes-Benz utilizes aggressive disciplinary measures to neutralize internal dissent. It is highly probable, given the “Never Again is Now” corporate stance, that similar mechanisms would be deployed against employees organizing for Palestinian rights, under the pretext of maintaining “political neutrality” or preventing antisemitism.

6.3 The Works Council (Betriebsrat) Stance

The General Works Council, a powerful body in German co-determination, has largely aligned with the management’s pro-Israel stance. Snippets indicate that major German unions like IG Metall (which dominates the Works Council) have lobbied for defense contracts. This alignment ensures that there is no internal labor opposition to the production and export of military vehicles to Israel, as these contracts secure German jobs.⁴⁷

1. Mercedes boss ‘deeply shaken’ by events since terrorist attacks against Israel, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.jewishnews.co.uk/mercedes-boss-deeply-shaken-by-events-since-terrorist-attacks-against-israel/
2. ‘Never again is now’: German companies condemn Hamas terror, stand with Israel, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.timesofisrael.com/never-again-is-now-german-companies-condemn-hamas-terror-stand-with-israel/
3. Transatlantic Partnership Award 2025 presented to Ola Källenius, CEO of Mercedes-Benz, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.amcham.de/news-details/transatlantic-partnership-award-2025-to-ola-kaellenius-ceo-of-mercedes-benz
4. Ola Källenius: The 100 Most Influential Climate Leaders of 2025 | TIME, accessed February 4, 2026, https://time.com/collections/time-100-climate-2025/7326573/ola-kallenius/
5. Renata Jungo Brüngger appointed Chair of the Board of Trustees, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.daimler-benz-stiftung.de/cms/en/renata-jungo-bruengger-appointed-chair-of-the-board-of-trustees.html
6. Status as of 31 December 2023 Renata Jungo Brüngger Thalkirch, Switzerland Member of the Board of Management of Mercedes-Benz – Munich Re, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.munichre.com/content/dam/munichre/contentlounge/website-pieces/documents/CV_Jungo-Bruengger_en.pdf/_jcr_content/renditions/original./CV_Jungo-Bruengger_en.pdf
7. Board of Directors – Atlantik-Brücke e.V., accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.atlantik-bruecke.org/en/atlantik-brucke/committees-of-atlantik-brucke-e-v/
8. Other Members of the Board – Atlantik-Brücke e.V., accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.atlantik-bruecke.org/en/atlantik-brucke/committees-of-atlantik-brucke-e-v/other-members-of-the-board/
9. KUNA : Kuwait seeks further multi-faceted cooperation with Mercedes-Benz – KIA chief – Economics – 11/04/2025 – كونا, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.kuna.net.kw/ArticleDetails.aspx?id=3225604&language=en
10. Mercedes-Benz Group Climate Policy Report 2022, accessed February 4, 2026, https://group.mercedes-benz.com/dokumente/investoren/berichte/geschaeftsberichte/mercedes-benz/mercedes-benz-ir-climate-policy-report-fy-2022.pdf
11. Joint Statement on Ukraine – United States Department of State, accessed February 4, 2026, https://2021-2025.state.gov/joint-statement-on-ukraine-2/
12. BMW, Mercedes, Audi: Have the German ‘Big Three’ Left Russia? – B4Ukraine, accessed February 4, 2026, https://b4ukraine.org/whats-new/bmw-mercedes-audi
13. Mercedes-Benz to Sell Off Russian Assets to Local Investor – The Moscow Times, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/10/26/mercedes-benz-to-sell-off-russian-assets-to-local-investor-a79196
14. Ford and Mercedes-Benz complete their exits from Russia – CBS News, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ford-mercedes-benz-russia-ukraine-exit/
15. Mercedes-Benz refutes false statements about its donations to Support Humanitarian Aid in the Middle East, accessed February 4, 2026, https://group.mercedes-benz.com/sustainability/society-governance/corporate-citizenship/donation-statements.html
16. The Israeli Occupation Industry – Mercedes Benz – Who Profits, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.whoprofits.org/companies/company/7399?mercedes-benz
17. Mercedes-Benz Group AG | AFSC Investigate – American Friends Service Committee, accessed February 4, 2026, https://investigate.afsc.org/company/mercedes-benz-group
18. United Hatzalah Adds Four Ambulances for Stronger Response, accessed February 4, 2026, https://israelrescue.org/stories/united-hatzalah-welcomes-four-new-ambulances-to-strengthen-emergency-response-fleet/
19. accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.whoprofits.org/companies/company/7399?mercedes-benz#:~:text=The%20Mercedes%20Arcos%20heavy%2Dduty,in%20Gaza%20during%20the%20Genocide.
20. Israel-Hamas war: Delivery of Mercedes IDF tank carriers speeds up | The Jerusalem Post, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.jpost.com/business-and-innovation/all-news/article-775255
21. Mercedes-Benz Plant Charleston | Mercedes-Benz Group > Company > Production > Procuction Network, accessed February 4, 2026, https://group.mercedes-benz.com/company/locations/production-network-charleston.html
22. Mercedes-Benz Vans opens new Sprinter plant in North Charleston – Amazon becomes the world’s largest Sprinter customer – PR Newswire, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/mercedes-benz-vans-opens-new-sprinter-plant-in-north-charleston—amazon-becomes-the-worlds-largest-sprinter-customer-300707125.html
23. In Shadow of War, a Snapshot of US Military Assistance to Israel – Stimson Center, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.stimson.org/2023/in-shadow-of-war-a-snapshot-of-u-s-military-assistance-to-israel/
24. The Israeli Ministry of Defense handed over armored ambulances to Ukraine – Militarnyi, accessed February 4, 2026, https://militarnyi.com/en/news/the-israeli-ministry-of-defense-handed-over-armored-ambulances-to-ukraine/
25. Israel delivers 3 more armored ambulances to Ukraine amid requests for military aid, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-delivers-3-more-armored-ambulances-to-ukraine-amid-requests-for-military-aid/
26. MBZ Unimog for Police and Peacekeeping Operations – Army Technology, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.army-technology.com/products/mbz-unimog-operations/
27. Mercedes-Benz Special Trucks ~ Defence Vehicles Experience | Joint Forces News, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.joint-forces.com/world-news/47183-mercedes-benz-special-trucks-defence-vehicles-experience
28. Base vehicles model series 464 – G-Class Governmental Business – Mercedes-Benz, accessed February 4, 2026, https://ggb.mercedes-benz.com/en/vehicles/base-vehicles-model-series-464
29. New liaison and patrol vehicle for Israel Defense Forces – ESUT, accessed February 4, 2026, https://esut.de/en/2021/10/meldungen/30338/neues-verbindungs-und-patrouillenfahrzeug-fuer-israelische-streitkraefte/
30. Microsoft storing Israeli intelligence trove used to attack Palestinians – +972 Magazine, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.972mag.com/microsoft-8200-intelligence-surveillance-cloud-azure/
31. Trend Analysis The Israeli Unit 8200 An OSINT-based study CSS CYBER DEFENSE PROJECT – CSS ETH Zürich, accessed February 4, 2026, https://css.ethz.ch/content/dam/ethz/special-interest/gess/cis/center-for-securities-studies/pdfs/Cyber-Reports-2019-12-Unit-8200.pdf
32. Mercedes-Benz Research & Development Tel Aviv Ltd., accessed February 4, 2026, https://group.mercedes-benz.com/careers/about-us/locations/location-detail-page-138432.html
33. Mercedes-Benz’s Enters European Ride-Sharing Market With Israeli Startup Via, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.weizmann-usa.org/news-media/in-the-news/mercedes-benz-s-enters-european-ride-sharing-market-with-israeli-startup-via/
34. Israeli start-up announces collaboration with Mercedes-Benz… – Gauzy, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.gauzy.com/articles/israeli-start-up-announces-collaboration-with-mercedes-benz/
35. Israel Innovation Authority to Sign Cooperation Agreement With Automotive Supplier Adler Pelzer | Ctech, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3749340,00.html
36. International Automotive Supplier Adler Pelzer Group to Sign Cooperation Agreement with Israel Innovation Authority, accessed February 4, 2026, https://innovationisrael.org.il/en/press_release/international-automotive-supplier-adler-pelzer-group-sign-cooperation-agreement-israel/
37. Ecomotion – Smart Mobility Community, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.ecomotion.org.il/
38. Our Partners | Ecomotion Week 2023 – Mobility 360 | May 22nd-24th, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.ecomotionweek.com/partners2023
39. Mercedes Benz invites Israelis to take part in its In-Car Coding Community for new apps | Ctech, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3889561,00.html
40. DLD Tel Aviv Innovation Festival – Foreign Trade Administration Agenda – south-africa, accessed February 4, 2026, https://itrade.gov.il/south-africa/2018/08/29/dld-tel-aviv-innovation-festival-foreign-trade-administration-agenda/
41. German-Israeli Chamber of Industry & Commerce, accessed February 4, 2026, https://israel.ahk.de/en
42. 2023, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.stiftung-evz.de/assets/4_Service/Infothek/Publikationen/T%C3%A4tigkeitsberichte/Englisch/evz_tb_2023_ENGL_web.pdf
43. Major German Companies, Including Daimler, VW and Deutsche Bank, Adopt IHRA Definition of Antisemitism | Algemeiner.com, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.algemeiner.com/2021/01/26/major-german-companies-including-daimler-vw-and-deutsche-bank-adopt-ihra-definition-of-antisemitism/
44. The foundation of our actions – our attitude. | Mercedes-Benz Group, accessed February 4, 2026, https://group.mercedes-benz.com/sustainability/society-governance/attitude/
45. Alabama Workers File Federal Charges Against Mercedes-Benz, Request Government Injunction to End Company’s Illegal Union Busting – UAW, accessed February 4, 2026, https://uaw.org/alabama-workers-file-federal-charges-against-mercedes-benz-request-government-injunction-to-end-companys-illegal-union-busting/
46. Mercedes-Benz Under Investigation by German Government for Illegally Violating Workers Rights at Alabama Plant – UAW, accessed February 4, 2026, https://uaw.org/mercedes-benz-under-investigation-by-german-government-for-illegally-violating-workers-rights-at-alabama-plant/
47. German trade unions support Israel’s genocide in Gaza – World Socialist Web Site, accessed February 4, 2026, https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2023/11/14/wgss-n14.html