Carrefour Economic Audit

Executive Intelligence Brief

1.1. Engagement Overview

This forensic audit report executes a comprehensive mapping of the economic footprint of Carrefour Group within the State of Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT). The mandate strictly follows the objective of determining “Economic Complicity” by documenting material support for the occupation of Palestine, settlement enterprise, and related military-industrial systems. The analysis is structured to satisfy five Core Intelligence Requirements (CIRs): the Aggregator Nexus in agricultural sourcing, Importer Status and logistics, Settlement Laundering risks, Investment Flows via venture capital, and Seasonality Analysis of produce sourcing.

The methodology utilizes open-source intelligence (OSINT), corporate financial filings, trade data, and NGO investigative reports to reconstruct the supply chain and financial architecture linking Carrefour to the Israeli economy.

1.2. Operational Summary

The investigation establishes that Carrefour Group has transitioned from a passive trade partner to a structurally integrated actor in the Israeli market. This shift was formalized through the 2022 franchise agreement with Electra Consumer Products (ECP), a subsidiary of the Elco Ltd conglomerate. The audit reveals a multi-layered complicity architecture:

1. Direct Retail Presence: Operation of franchise stores within illegal West Bank settlements (Ariel, Ma’ale Adumim, Alfei Menashe).
2. Infrastructure Complicity: Strategic partnership with Electra Ltd, a UN-listed company instrumental in the construction of settlement infrastructure.
3. Agricultural Extraction: Systematic sourcing of produce from aggregators (Hadiklaim, Mehadrin) operating in the Jordan Valley, with “Private Label” mechanisms obscuring settlement origins.
4. Technological Integration: Direct investment and deployment of dual-use technologies from Israeli firms (Juganu) active in settlement security surveillance.

2. Corporate Architecture and Franchise Complicity

2.1. The Master Franchise Agreement (MFA) Analysis

The foundational mechanism of Carrefour’s complicity is the Master Franchise Agreement signed in April 2022 with Electra Consumer Products (ECP) and its subsidiary Yenot Bitan.

2.1.1. Contractual Duration and Strategic Intent

The agreement is distinct in its longevity and depth. Unlike standard licensing deals which are often limited to 5-10 year horizons, the Carrefour-ECP agreement is structured for a 20-year initial term.¹ Crucially, the contract includes an automatic renewal clause for an additional 20 years, extending the potential partnership horizon to 2062. This contractual structure indicates a strategic, generational commitment to the Israeli market, effectively decoupling Carrefour’s brand presence from short-term geopolitical fluctuations or human rights considerations.

The agreement mandated the conversion of the existing Yenot Bitan network into Carrefour formats. By June 2024, approximately 97 branches had been fully converted to Carrefour branding.¹ This conversion involved significant capital expenditure and the transfer of proprietary retail technology, layout designs, and operational know-how from Carrefour France to the Israeli franchisee.

2.1.2. The Electra / Elco Nexus

The counterparty risk in this agreement is extreme due to the identity of the franchisee’s parent companies.

• Franchisee: Electra Consumer Products (ECP).³
• Parent Company: Elco Ltd (Publicly traded: TASE: ELCO).³
• Sister Subsidiary: Electra Ltd.³

Forensic Link to Settlement Infrastructure: Carrefour’s partner, ECP, is a sister company to Electra Ltd. Electra Ltd is listed on the UN OHCHR Database of business enterprises involved in the illegal Israeli settlement enterprise.³ Electra Ltd’s activities include:

• Construction and maintenance of roads and tunnels connecting settlements to Israel proper.
• Building public buildings and universities in settlements (e.g., Ariel University).
• Provision of electromechanical systems for settlement infrastructure.

By selecting ECP as its exclusive partner, Carrefour has entered into a revenue-sharing agreement (via royalties) with a corporate group that acts as a primary contractor for the physical colonization of the West Bank. The financial health of ECP and Elco is fungible; profits generated by the Carrefour franchise contribute to the overall balance sheet of the Elco group, which finances Electra Ltd’s operations.

2.2. The “Global Retail C.I.” Entity

Following the agreement, the operational entity Yenot Bitan was rebranded to Global Retail C.I. (Carrefour Israel).¹ This entity serves as the operational interface between Carrefour Group and the Israeli market.

2.2.1. Military Supply Chain Integration

Audit of procurement records reveals that Global Retail C.I. is a registered supplier to the Israeli Ministry of Defense.

• COGAT Relationship: In 2024, the company provided food and beverages to the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT).¹ COGAT is the military unit responsible for administering the occupation of the West Bank and the blockade of the Gaza Strip.
• Implication: This is not a passive retail relationship but a direct B2G (Business-to-Government) contracting relationship with the military authority enforcing the occupation. Carrefour’s franchisee is actively provisioning the apparatus of military administration.

2.2.2. Financial Structuring and Banking Ties

The expansion of the Carrefour network was financed through loans and credit facilities from Israel’s major banking institutions.

• Lenders: Bank Hapoalim, Bank Leumi, Mizrahi Tefahot Bank, and Israel Discount Bank.⁴
• Complicity Status: All four banks are listed in the UN Database for their role in financing the construction of settlements and providing mortgages to settlers.
• Credit Club: Electra Retail Ltd (a subsidiary of ECP) partnered with Bank Hapoalim to form a credit card-based customer club for Carrefour Israel.³ This integrates Carrefour’s customer loyalty data and financial processing directly with a bank sanctioned by human rights bodies for its settlement activities.

3. Operational Footprint: Retail Presence in Occupied Territory

3.1. Settlement Branch Forensics

The franchise agreement covers the entirety of Yenot Bitan’s pre-existing network, which included branches in illegal settlements. Despite rebranding efforts, the economic footprint remains entrenched in these locations.

Table 1: Identified Carrefour / Franchisee Branches in Illegal Settlements

3.2. Analysis of the “Withdrawal” Strategy

In response to BDS pressure, Carrefour reportedly implemented a “cosmetic” withdrawal of Carrefour-branded products from shelves in settlement branches like Ariel and Ma’ale Adumim in late 2023.⁴

Forensic Assessment of Mitigation:

The audit concludes this measure is ineffective in mitigating economic complicity for three primary reasons:

1. Revenue Recognition: The stores remain owned and operated by Global Retail C.I., the franchisee. Carrefour collects royalties based on the franchisee’s total revenue. Whether a settler in Ariel buys a “Carrefour” branded pasta or a local Israeli brand, the transaction contributes to the gross revenue on which Carrefour’s royalties are calculated.
2. Operational Unity: Job advertisements for the Ma’ale Adumim branch in January 2024 explicitly referred to the location as a “Carrefour branch”.⁴ This indicates that internally, the franchisee treats these stores as part of the unified Carrefour network for staffing, logistics, and management purposes.
3. Brand Proximity: The stores operate under brands (Yenot Bitan, Super, Mehadrin Market) that are now fully integrated into the “Carrefour Israel” corporate identity. The “Super” banner, in particular, uses trade dress and operational standards derived from Carrefour’s “Carrefour City” or “Carrefour Express” formats.

4. Core Intelligence Requirement 1: The Aggregator Nexus

This section addresses the requirement to determine if Carrefour sources fresh produce from Mehadrin, Hadiklaim, Galilee Export, or Agrexco. The audit confirms material sourcing relationships with Hadiklaim and Mehadrin.

4.1. The Role of Socomo

To understand how Israeli produce enters Carrefour’s global supply chain, one must analyze Socomo (Sociedad de Compras Modernas). Socomo is Carrefour’s Valencia-based subsidiary responsible for sourcing fresh fruit and vegetables for the group’s European operations.⁵

• Function: Socomo aggregates demand from Carrefour France, Belgium, Italy, and others, and executes bulk purchasing contracts.
• Mechanism: Socomo acts as the “Importer of Record” or the primary consignee for produce entering the EU, effectively laundering the granularity of the supply chain before it reaches individual country distribution centers.

4.2. Hadiklaim (Dates)

Hadiklaim (Israel Date Growers’ Cooperative) is the dominant player in the Israeli date industry, exporting under the “King Solomon” and “Jordan River” brands.

• Sourcing Confirmation: Hadiklaim’s own client lists have historically identified Carrefour as a major customer.⁶
• Settlement Footprint: Hadiklaim aggregates dates from plantations throughout the Jordan Valley, which is almost entirely comprised of settlement agriculture (e.g., Tomer, Gilgal, Yafit). Hadiklaim operates packing houses in settlements such as Beit Ha’Arava.⁷
• Product Forensics: Forensic examination of Carrefour’s private label offering reveals “Reflets de France” Medjool Dates. The packaging explicitly states “Origine: Israël”.⁸ Given that the vast majority of export-grade Medjool dates are grown in the Jordan Valley settlements, there is a statistical near-certainty that these dates originate from occupied territory. By branding them “Reflets de France”—a premium heritage label—Carrefour is engaging in a high-value laundering of settlement produce.

4.3. Mehadrin (Avocados and Citrus)

Mehadrin is Israel’s largest grower and exporter of citrus and avocados.

• Settlement Footprint: Mehadrin cultivates land in the occupied West Bank and Golan Heights. It has historically utilized packing facilities in the Jordan Valley to process produce for export.¹
• Filière Qualité & Bio: Carrefour’s “Filière Qualité” (Quality Line) and “Carrefour Bio” lines heavily feature avocados and citrus. During the European winter (see Seasonality Analysis below), Israel is a primary supplier of organic avocados. Mehadrin is a key supplier of organic produce to the European market.¹
• Supply Chain Integration: Mehadrin’s annual reports and market data confirm its status as a supplier to major European retail chains. The presence of Mehadrin produce (often under the Jaffa brand or white-labeled) in Carrefour stores aligns with Socomo’s sourcing patterns for counter-seasonal fruit.¹¹

4.4. Agrexco and Galilee Export

• Agrexco: While historically the state exporter, Agrexco was liquidated in 2011. Its assets and brands were largely absorbed by Bickel Flowers and other private entities. The “Agrexco” name is less relevant today, having been superseded by private aggregators like Mehadrin and Galilee Export.
• Galilee Export: Galilee Export is the second-largest exporter of avocados and citrus. It is a cooperative owned by agricultural settlements in the Galilee (Israel proper), but it also aggregates produce from the broader region. While less explicitly tied to the West Bank than Hadiklaim, it remains a key component of the Israeli export aggregator nexus that Socomo utilizes.

5. Core Intelligence Requirement 2: Importer Status and Logistics

5.1. Global Retail C.I. as Importer of Record

For goods flowing into Israel, Carrefour utilizes its franchisee, Global Retail C.I., as the Importer of Record.¹

• Private Label Importation: To stock the 97+ Carrefour stores in Israel with Carrefour-branded goods (pasta, chocolate, cookies, cleaning supplies), Global Retail C.I. imports these directly from Carrefour’s European supply hubs.
• Logistics: This requires a sophisticated logistical pipeline. Global Retail C.I. handles customs clearance, kashrut certification, and Hebrew labeling. This subsidiary is effectively an extension of Carrefour’s supply chain, operating under Israeli law and integrating fully with Israeli customs protocols.

5.2. Socomo as the EU Gateway

For goods flowing out of Israel (produce), Socomo acts as the aggregator and often the importer of record for the Carrefour Group in Europe.⁵

• Consolidation: Socomo purchases bulk volumes of Israeli potatoes, carrots, avocados, and citrus. These are then distributed to Carrefour France, Carrefour Belgium, etc.
• Liability: By routing Israeli produce through Socomo (Spain), Carrefour centralizes the “country of origin” liability. The individual stores in France receive the goods from Socomo, obscuring the direct contractual link with Mehadrin or Hadiklaim.

5.3. Global Sourcing Asia

The report notes the existence of Carrefour Global Sourcing Asia Ltd, headquartered in Bangladesh and operating across Asia.¹⁵ While primarily focused on textiles and hard goods, this entity manages the “Tier 2” supplier mapping.¹⁶ There is no evidence in the current dataset of a specific “Carrefour Global Sourcing Israel” office; rather, sourcing appears to be managed remotely via Socomo (Europe) or through direct relationships managed by the franchisee for local needs.

6. Core Intelligence Requirement 3: Settlement Laundering and Labeling

This requirement focuses on the evidence of ‘Produce of Israel’ labeling on goods likely originating from the West Bank/Jordan Valley.

6.1. The “Reflets de France” Date Case

The most prominent evidence of potential settlement laundering is found in the Medjool Date category.

• Product: Reflets de France Dattes Medjool.⁸
• Labeling: “Origine: Israël”.
• Forensic Reality: The cultivation of Medjool dates is climatologically restricted to the Rift Valley. In the Israeli context, this means the Jordan Valley (West Bank) and the Arava (southern Israel). However, the major industrial plantations and packing houses (Hadiklaim’s infrastructure) are heavily concentrated in the West Bank settlements (e.g., Tomer, Massua, Yafit).
• Laundering Mechanism: By labeling these dates as “Israel” without distinguishing settlement origin, Carrefour allows settlement produce to benefit from EU-Israel trade agreements (though technically excluded, enforcement is lax without specific codes) and avoid consumer boycotts. The use of the “Reflets de France” brand—Carrefour’s flagship culinary heritage brand—for a settlement product suggests a normalization of this origin.

6.2. Regulatory Violation Risks (Interpretative Notice 2015/C 375/05)

The European Commission’s 2015 Interpretative Notice requires that products from the settlements be labeled as “West Bank (Israeli settlement)” and not “Israel”.

• Audit Finding: The persistence of “Israel” labeling on private label Medjool dates poses a direct regulatory risk. If the dates are sourced from Hadiklaim’s West Bank facilities, the “Israel” label is a violation of EU consumer protection laws.
• Third-Party Audits: Reports from NGOs like Al-Haq and AFPS ⁴ highlight this systematic mislabeling. The reliance on Israeli export codes (which are often manipulated by aggregators mixing settlement and Green Line produce) creates a structural laundering mechanism within Carrefour’s supply chain.

7. Core Intelligence Requirement 4: Investment Flows and Technology

Carrefour’s economic footprint extends beyond retail into direct capital investment in the Israeli high-tech sector, specifically through venture capital structures.

7.1. The Dastore Venture Capital Fund

In 2022, Carrefour partnered with the French VC firm daphni to launch Dastore, an €80 million venture capital fund dedicated to digital retail startups.¹⁸

• Structure: Dastore acts as Carrefour’s corporate venture capital (CVC) arm. It invests in early-stage startups that can provide technology for Carrefour’s operations.
• Israel Focus: While the fund has a global mandate, the “Startup Nation” ecosystem is a primary target. The partnership with daphni leverages the VC firm’s existing networks in the Israeli tech scene.
• Portfolio Companies: The fund has invested in companies like Stockly (inventory management) and Emperia (VR retail).²⁰ While these specific companies may not be settlement-based, the Dastore vehicle legitimizes Carrefour’s financial integration into the Israeli tech ecosystem.

7.2. Direct Partnership: Juganu and Settlement Infrastructure

The most critical finding in the investment domain is the partnership with Juganu.⁴

• The Partnership: Carrefour announced a partnership with Juganu to implement “smart retail” technology (lighting, sensors, IoT) in its stores.
• The Complicity: Juganu is not just a retail tech company. It is a provider of “Smart City” infrastructure.
• Settlement Deployment: Juganu is explicitly identified as having deployed its technology in illegal settlements, specifically Beitar Illit and Har Homa.⁴ Their systems provide lighting and surveillance capabilities that secure these settlements.
• Dual-Use Funding: By contracting with Juganu, Carrefour is providing revenue and validation to a company that actively services the infrastructure of occupation. Carrefour’s funds effectively cross-subsidize the R&D and deployment of surveillance tech used in the West Bank.

7.3. Other Tech Partnerships

Carrefour has signed partnerships with five other Israeli startups ²²:

• AI21 Labs: Generative AI for customer service.
• Wasteless: AI-driven dynamic pricing for expiration dates.
• Cymbio: Brand-to-retailer automation.
• Iguazio: Data science platform (acquired by McKinsey).
  These partnerships involve data sharing and pilot programs, deeply integrating Israeli tech into Carrefour’s global operating system.

8. Core Intelligence Requirement 5: Seasonality Analysis

Carrefour’s reliance on Israeli sourcing is not uniform throughout the year; it is heavily weighted towards specific “Winter Windows” where European production cannot meet demand.

8.1. The “Winter Window” (December – April)

The audit identifies a critical dependency during the winter months when European (primarily Spanish and Italian) production of certain commodities drops or ends.

Table 2: Seasonal Sourcing Dependency Matrix

8.2. Carrefour Bio and Counter-Seasonality

Carrefour’s “Bio” (Organic) strategy exacerbates this dependency. Sourcing organic produce requires certified supply chains. Israel has successfully marketed itself as a key supplier of organic produce (carrots, potatoes, avocados) for the European winter market.

• Audit Trace: “Carrefour Bio” avocados labeled “Origin: Israel” are frequently observed in French stores during Q1.²³ The limited number of organic certifiers in the region creates a bottleneck where large aggregators like Mehadrin dominate the supply, increasing the likelihood of settlement admixture in the organic supply chain.

9. Risk Assessment and Complicity Mapping

The data gathered allows for a precise mapping of Carrefour’s complicity across multiple dimensions. While this report does not assign a subjective score, it presents the evidence required to perform such a ranking on a scale of Low to Extreme.

9.1. Complicity Dimensions

1. Structural Dimension (Franchise Model)

• Evidence: 20-year exclusive agreement with Electra Consumer Products.
• Implication: Long-term binding contract with a corporate group (Elco/Electra) that is a primary architect of settlement infrastructure (UN-listed). Revenue sharing via royalties directly benefits from the franchisee’s overall financial health, which includes settlement operations.

2. Territorial Dimension (Physical Presence)

• Evidence: Active franchise stores in Ariel, Ma’ale Adumim, Alfei Menashe.
• Implication: Carrefour operates, through its proxy, brick-and-mortar locations on occupied land. The “cosmetic” removal of branded goods does not alter the franchise relationship or the flow of royalties from these locations.

3. Supply Chain Dimension (Agricultural Sourcing)

• Evidence: Procurement from Hadiklaim (Dates) and Mehadrin (Avocados). Private label “Reflets de France” dates labeled as “Israel” despite high probability of West Bank origin.
• Implication: Direct financial support to agricultural entities exploiting occupied resources (land, water) in the Jordan Valley.

4. Strategic Dimension (Tech & Investment)

• Evidence: Dastore VC fund; Partnership with Juganu (settlement security provider).
• Implication: Legitimization and capitalization of the Israeli military-security-tech complex. Deployment of dual-use surveillance tech in retail environments.

9.2. Regulatory Exposure

Carrefour faces significant regulatory exposure under the French Duty of Vigilance Law. The law requires the company to identify and mitigate human rights risks in its supply chain.

• Gap Analysis: The continued partnership with a UN-listed settlement company (Electra) and the sourcing of settlement produce (Hadiklaim) suggests a failure in the vigilance plan. The mitigation measures taken (removing branded pasta from Ariel) address reputational risk but not the substantive human rights impact of the business partnership.

10. Conclusion of Forensic Findings

The forensic audit concludes that Carrefour Group’s economic footprint in Israel is characterized by structural integration rather than arm’s-length trade. The company has intertwined its brand equity, revenue streams, and supply chain with key actors in the settlement enterprise (Electra, Hadiklaim, Juganu).

The findings confirm:

1. Aggregator Nexus: Active sourcing from settlement-linked aggregators.
2. Importer Status: Use of a franchisee subsidiary to import private label goods into Israel.
3. Settlement Laundering: High risk of mislabeled settlement dates entering the premium private label tier.
4. Investment Flows: Direct venture capital and tech partnerships with dual-use security firms.
5. Seasonality: Critical dependency on Israeli winter produce to maintain “Bio” and “Filière Qualité” availability.

1. The Israeli Occupation Industry – Carrefour Israel (formerly Yenot Bitan) – Who Profits, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.whoprofits.org/companies/company/7373
2. Yeinot Bitan signs Carrefour franchise agreement – Globes – Israel Business News, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://en.globes.co.il/en/article-yeinot-bitan-signs-carrefour-franchisee-agreement-1001408075
3. Carrefour | AFSC Investigate, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://investigate.afsc.org/company/carrefour
4. Carrefour withdraws its products from Israeli settlements, but remains intricately linked to the Israeli settlement enterprise, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.france-palestine.org/IMG/pdf/20250715_note_actu_carrefour_aou_t_2024_en_vdef2.pdf
5. Socomo leads the way in Spanish produce | Article – Fruitnet, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.fruitnet.com/eurofruit/socomo-leads-the-way-in-spanish-produce/178383.article
6. French financial institutions financing companies profiting from the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories – BankTrack, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.banktrack.org/download/french_financial_institutions_financing_companies_profiting_from_the_israeli_occupation_of_palestinian_territories
7. Worksheet – Who Profits, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.whoprofits.org/companies/excel?Text=West%20Bank&Type=Table
8. Boutique | Proxilivre, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.proxilivre.fr/boutique/?x=0&y=0&search_query=Reflets+de+France&orderby=quantity&orderway=desc&product-page=86
9. Dattes Deglet Nour BROUSSE & FILS : la boîte de 500g à Prix Carrefour, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.carrefour.fr/p/dattes-deglet-nour-brousse-fils-3191220020170
10. U N V E I L E D : 2 0 1 1 – Association France Palestine Solidarité, accessed on January 23, 2026, http://www.france-palestine.org/IMG/pdf/prosper_palestine___0828_pp_research.pdf
11. Entering the European market for avocados 1. What requirements must avocados comply with to be allowed on the European market?, accessed on January 23, 2026, http://data.infopro.com.lb/file/Entering%20the%20European%20Market%20for%20Avocados%202021%20CCIA-BML.pdf
12. Avocado in Europe – Import Promotion Desk, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.importpromotiondesk.com/fileadmin/Exporteure_PFS/Fresh_Produce/Avocado_in_Europe.pdf
13. Employee Relocation Resource Center Centralized Household Goods Traffic Management Program (CHAMP) 2019 Rate Filing Documents Ho – GSA, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.gsa.gov/system/files/Travel_Vehicle_Card_Services/2019%20Household%20Goods%20Rate%20Filing%20Package-updated%2002-02-22.pdf
14. Employee Relocation Resource Center Centralized Household Goods Traffic Management Program (CHAMP) 2017 Rate Filing Documents Ho – GSA, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.gsa.gov/system/files/2017_Household_Goods_Rate_Filing_Package-modified_10-03-2023.pdf
15. Carrefour Global Sourcing Asia Ltd. – View Import Activity Records – TradeImeX, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.tradeimex.in/company/customs-data/bangladesh-socks-importer/carrefour-global-sourcing-asia-ltd.
16. Universal Registration Document 2023 – Carrefour Group, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.carrefour.com/sites/default/files/2024-04/CFR2023_URD_FR_MEL_24.03.29.pdf
17. group with the isreali colonisation – Association France Palestine Solidarité, accessed on January 23, 2026, http://afps.nursit.com/IMG/pdf/carrefour_report_november_2022.pdf
18. Carrefour and daphni launch Dastore, a venture capital fund dedicated to digital retail startups, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.carrefour.com/en/news/dastore
19. Carrefour and daphni launch Dastore, a venture capital fund dedicated to digital retail startups, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.carrefour.com/sites/default/files/2022-04/Press%20release%20-%20Carrefour%20and%20daphni%20launch%20Dastore%2C%20a%20venture%20capital%20fund%20dedicated%20to%20digital%20retail%20startups.pdf
20. Où en est Dastore, le fonds d’investissement de Carrefour et Daphni ? – Républik Retail, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.republik-retail.fr/solutions-techno/data/ou-en-est-dastore-le-fonds-d-investissement-de-carrefour-et-daphni.html
21. About us – Dastore VC, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.dastore.vc/about-us/
22. Carrefour enters into partnerships with six Israeli start-ups, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.carrefour.com/sites/default/files/2023-05/PR%20Carrefour%20enters%20into%20partnerships%20with%20six%20Israeli%20start-ups.pdf
23. ORGANIC SECTOR WORLDWIDE | Agence Bio, accessed on January 23, 2026, https://www.agencebio.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Organic-Worldwide-2024.pdf