Contents

Apple

  • Last Updated: November 18, 2025
  • No Comments
BDS Rating
Grade
A
BDS Score
850
V-MIL
8
V-ECON
8.8
V-POL
7.5
Open Full Report

1. Executive Dossier Summary

Company: Apple Inc.1

Jurisdiction: United States (HQ: Cupertino, California) 1

Sector: Consumer Electronics, Software Services, Artificial Intelligence 2

Leadership: Tim Cook (Chief Executive Officer), Arthur D. Levinson (Chairman) 2

Intelligence Conclusions:

  • Deep Economic Entanglement: Apple’s operations in Israel constitute a core component of its global R&D strategy, not a peripheral outpost. With approximately 2,500 employees 7, it functions as Apple’s second-largest R&D hub globally 8, responsible for developing critical, high-value intellectual property, including its flagship “M” series silicon chips.10 This structurally embeds Apple as a pillar of the Israeli high-tech economy.
  • Structural Reliance on Military-Intelligence Pipeline: A documented pattern of strategic acquisitions—most notably PrimeSense (E004), founded by alumni of the IDF’s elite Unit 8200 12—demonstrates Apple’s deliberate and repeated harvesting of talent and technology from the Israeli military-intelligence ecosystem.
  • Direct Financial Support for IDF & Illegal Settlements: Apple maintains a corporate employee donation matching program (via the Benevity platform) that actively and, as of late 2024, knowingly includes and matches funds for “Friends of the IDF” (FIDF) and multiple U.S.-based organizations (One Israel Fund, HaYovel) that openly finance the expansion of illegal settlements in the Occupied West Bank.15
  • Systemic Internal Suppression & Anti-Palestinian Bias: A stark contradiction exists between Apple’s public “Commitment to Human Rights” 19 and its internal actions post-October 7, 2023. This includes one-sided leadership statements acknowledging Israeli but not Palestinian suffering 20 and a documented pattern of “wrongful termination” and retaliation against employees for expressing Palestinian solidarity.21
  • Calculated Brand Management: Apple simultaneously executes a sophisticated brand-defense strategy by publicly suing Israeli “mercenary spyware” firms like NSO Group 26 while operating a token R&D center in the West Bank (Rawabi) 27 as a public relations offset. This strategy allows it to project an image of human rights advocacy while deepening its structural and financial complicity.
  • Governance Aligned with Military-Industrial Complex: Apple’s Board of Directors includes Ronald D. Sugar, the former CEO and Chairman of Northrop Grumman, a top-tier U.S. arms manufacturer.5 Sugar chairs Apple’s Audit and Finance Committee 6, signaling a deep, high-level alignment with the U.S. military-industrial complex, which counts Israel as a key strategic partner.

2. Corporate Overview & Evolution

Origins & Founders

Apple Inc. was founded on April 1, 1976, in Los Altos, California, by Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, and Ronald Wayne.2 The company’s origins are rooted in the nascent U.S. personal computer and consumer electronics market.

Assessment: No evidence suggests the company’s founding, mission, or initial capital was linked to Israeli, diaspora, or Zionist networks. Its current, deep-seated relationships with Israeli state and military-aligned interests are the result of deliberate strategic evolution and market choices made over the last two decades, not a foundational ideology.

Leadership & Ownership

  • Chief Executive Officer: Tim Cook.2 Cook maintains a public persona of neutrality on most political issues.31 However, following the October 7, 2023 attacks, he issued a public-facing internal memo acknowledging Israeli suffering while pointedly omitting any mention of Palestinian suffering or the humanitarian crisis in Gaza.20 This one-sided statement has been maintained despite significant internal pressure and open letters from employees.20
  • Chairman: Arthur D. Levinson.2 Levinson is the founder and CEO of Calico. No known overt public alignment on this issue has been identified.
  • Board Member: Ronald D. Sugar.5 Sugar is the former Chairman and CEO (2003-2010) of Northrop Grumman Corporation 5, one of the world’s largest defense contractors and a major supplier of advanced weaponry to the Israeli military. Sugar joined Apple’s board in 2010 34 and, most critically, serves as the Chair of the Audit and Finance Committee.6

Assessment: The presence of Ronald D. Sugar on the board is the most significant leadership link. This is not “guilt by association” but a deliberate governance choice by Apple. Placing the former head of a premier U.S. arms manufacturer as the Chair of the Audit and Finance Committee—the body responsible for risk oversight—is a profound statement. It signals a deep, structural alignment with the U.S. military-industrial complex (MIC). This MIC-aligned governance model inherently views a deep relationship with Israel—a key U.S. military partner and R&D outpost—as a strategic asset and a normal, “business as usual” risk, rather than a human rights liability. This worldview provides the context for Tim Cook’s one-sided statements 20 and the company’s internal suppression of dissent; these actions are coherent with a corporate governance model that is institutionally aligned with U.S. foreign policy and the defense industry.

Operations & Presence: Israel

Apple operates its second-largest global R&D hub in Israel.8 This operation is not a peripheral sales office but a core component of Apple’s global engineering and innovation strategy.

  • Locations: Major R&D centers are located in Herzliya (inaugurated 2015) 8, Haifa 10, and Jerusalem (opened 2022).11
  • Scale: The operation employs approximately 2,500 people in Israel.7
  • Strategic Function: The Israeli R&D centers are not a support function. They are led by Apple Senior Vice President of Hardware Technologies, Johny Srouji (an Israeli Arab from Haifa) 8, and are responsible for developing core Apple intellectual property. This includes the development of the company’s flagship M-series silicon chips for its Mac and iPad product lines.10

Assessment: This represents a strategic, structural, and critical economic tie. Apple is not merely “doing business in” Israel; it has made Israel a critical organ of its global R&D infrastructure. This provides the Israeli economy with thousands of high-wage jobs, substantial tax revenue, and the immense prestige of being the core engineering hub for the world’s most valuable company. This deep entanglement creates a powerful structural disincentive for Apple to criticize the Israeli state, as its most important product lines (Macs, iPads) are materially dependent on its Israeli operations.11

Operations & Presence: Palestine

Apple operates a small engineering hub in the Palestinian city of Rawabi, located in the Occupied West Bank.27

  • Scale: The hub, opened quietly in 2018 37 and publicly announced in 2022 28, employs approximately 60 Palestinian engineers.27 It operates in partnership with the Ramallah-based contractor ASAL Technologies.37
  • Function: The engineers reportedly work on projects including Apple Silicon and Face ID 40, collaborating with the Israeli teams in Haifa and Herzliya.37

Assessment: This operation is a token. The ~40-to-1 ratio of Israeli employees (2,500) to Palestinian employees (60) is a prosecutable fact that demonstrates its negligible scale and strategic irrelevance. The Rawabi office functions as a “PR offset” or “fig leaf.” It is a form of political and human rights plausible deniability. It allows Apple to claim it is “creating opportunities for Palestinian engineers” 28 and “addressing an important regional matter” 28, effectively using a handful of Palestinian engineers to provide a brand shield for its massive, structural investment in the Israeli military-tech economy. The public-facing use of SVP Johny Srouji 28, an Israeli-Arab, to announce this project further leverages identity to support a corporate narrative of “balance” and “co-existence.”

Public Positioning vs. Behaviour

  • Public Position: Apple’s “Human Rights Policy” (May 2025) explicitly commits the company to the UN Guiding Principles, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights 19, and to “treating everyone with dignity and respect”.19
  • Actual Behaviour (External): As detailed in Section 4, Apple’s corporate donation matching program directly funds the Israeli military (Friends of the IDF) and organizations building illegal settlements in the West Bank.15 This is a prima facie violation of international law (which its policy claims to respect) and the policy’s own eligibility criteria.15
  • Actual Behaviour (Internal): As detailed in Section 5, Apple’s leadership has maintained a one-sided silence 20, shut down internal Muslim/Arab employee channels 22, and engaged in a pattern of “wrongful termination” and retaliation against employees for wearing symbols of Palestinian identity.21

Assessment: The contradiction is systemic and demonstrates a clear hierarchy. Apple’s Human Rights Policy is a brand and compliance document, not an operative policy. When this policy conflicts with the company’s de facto geopolitical alignment, the alignment supersedes the policy. The internal suppression of Palestinian identity 45 while externally and financially supporting the IDF 17 is the clearest evidence of this operational hierarchy.

Core Sensitivity:

  • Apple’s active and knowing corporate policy of matching employee donations to “Friends of the IDF” and multiple U.S.-based 501(c)(3) organizations (One Israel Fund, HaYovel) that openly and systemically fund the construction and security of illegal, segregated settlements in the Occupied West Bank.15 This provides direct, material, and ideological support to entities that violate international law.

3. Timeline of Relevant Events

Date Event Significance
1985 Apple makes its first entry into Israel. Establishes an early, though limited, market presence.35
Dec 2011 Apple announces acquisition of Anobit for ~$390M. First major Israeli acquisition; signals strategic shift to Israel for core tech (flash memory). Becomes basis for first R&D center.9
Nov 2013 Apple acquires PrimeSense for ~$345M. Second major acquisition. PrimeSense (3D sensors) was founded by Unit 8200 alumni, formalizing the IDF-to-Apple talent pipeline.9
Apr 2015 Apple acquires LinX Computational Imaging for ~$20M. Continues pattern of acquiring Israeli imaging and surveillance-adjacent technology.12
Feb 2015 CEO Tim Cook visits Israel, inaugurates new Herzliya R&D center. Cook calls Israel Apple’s 2nd largest R&D hub; meets with President Rivlin, solidifying high-level state relations.8
Feb 2017 Apple acquires RealFace (facial recognition). Acquisition of another Israeli surveillance-adjacent tech company, strengthening its Face ID technology.12
2018 Apple quietly opens R&D hub in Rawabi, West Bank. Establishes a token presence (~60 employees) in Palestine, a move later used for PR.37
~2020 Apple acquires Camerai (camera technology). Continues pattern of absorbing Israeli AR/camera tech startups.51
Nov 2021 Apple files a lawsuit against NSO Group. Publicly positions Apple as an opponent of “state-sponsored spyware,” a move that provides a significant human rights/PR shield.26
Jun 2022 Apple publicly announces expansion of Rawabi R&D hub. SVP Johny Srouji frames the token hub as addressing a “regional matter,” leveraging it for a positive PR narrative.28
Jul 2022 Apple opens a new R&D center in Jerusalem. Expands R&D footprint into a contested city, further deepening its Israeli presence.11
Oct 9, 2023 CEO Tim Cook issues an internal memo on the “devastating” attacks in Israel. The memo, shared publicly, only mentions Israeli suffering, omitting any reference to Palestinians or Gaza.20
Nov 2023 Apple reportedly “pauses” and shuts down the internal “Muslims@Apple” Slack channel. The channel was a key space for employees to discuss the conflict; its shutdown is cited as an act of internal suppression.22
Mar 6, 2024 Apple fires employee Madly Espinoza. Espinoza, a Palestinian-American, is terminated for allegedly “breaking business conduct” by wearing a keffiyeh and “Save Gaza” bracelets.22
Apr 2, 2024 Employee group “Apples4Ceasefire” publishes an open letter. Letter details “wrongful terminations” and retaliation against employees for expressing Palestinian solidarity.20
Apr 13, 2024 Shareholders and employees publish an open letter demanding Apple stop matching donations to IDF/settlement groups. The letter specifically names FIDF, HaYovel, One Israel Fund, JNF, and IsraelGives, citing Apple’s own Benevity platform.15
Jun 2024 Media reports confirm Apple is matching donations to IDF and settlement-funding groups. Confirms the allegations in the April letter are factual and ongoing.17
Dec 2024 Reports indicate FIDF was briefly removed from Benevity but restored. This action removes any plausible deniability, proving Apple knows about the link and has re-approved it.18
Jan 2025 Apple acquires TrueMeeting. Latest in a long line of Israeli tech acquisitions, reinforcing the strategic R&D pipeline.48

4. Financial & Ownership Exposure

Investors / Shareholders:

As per the operational mandate, this analysis excludes passive, broad-market institutional investors (e.g., BlackRock, Vanguard) whose holdings are a function of global index funds and do not represent intentional or strategic ideological alignment. No specific high-complicity Israeli, diaspora, or Zionist-linked controlling shareholders were identified in the available data. The company’s complicity is driven by operational and philanthropic choices, not (in this case) by its ownership structure.

Contracts / Trade: Apple’s Israeli Strategic Acquisition Pipeline

Apple’s R&D presence in Israel was not built from scratch. It was accelerated by a deliberate, multi-year, multi-billion dollar strategy of acquiring key Israeli startups. This pattern of acquisitions is the evidence of a conscious, strategic choice to embed Apple’s future technology in the Israeli tech ecosystem, which is itself inextricably linked to the Israeli military.

Table: Apple’s Israeli Strategic Acquisition Pipeline

Entity / Source Year Est. Amount Technology Domain Significance & Military/Intelligence Links
Anobit 2011/12 $390–$500M Flash Memory Controllers Apple’s first and largest Israeli acquisition; formed the basis of the Herzliya R&D center. Founders: Ehud Weinstein, Ariel Maislos, Ofir Shalvi.9
PrimeSense 2013 $345M 3D Sensing (Kinect) Technology foundational to Face ID. Founders are alumni of IDF Intelligence Unit 8200.9
LinX 2015 $20M Multi-aperture cameras Tech for low-light performance, 3D models, and face identity. Acquired for iPhone camera technology.12
RealFace 2017 ~$2M Facial Recognition “Recognition software” with a “new way to enjoy photos.” Acquired for Face ID technology.12
Camerai ~2020 Undisclosed AR / Camera Tech Secretive acquisition, continues pattern of absorbing Israeli AR/imaging talent.51
TrueMeeting 2025 <$45M 3D Avatars Latest acquisition, strengthening Apple’s 3D/AR/Vision Pro development.48

Political / Philanthropic Donations (Direct Complicity)

This is the most direct evidence of intentional ideological and material support. Apple uses the Benevity platform (E012) for its corporate employee donation matching program.56 Critically, Apple approves the 501(c)(3) organizations eligible for this matching.18

Open letters from shareholders and employees (Apples4Ceasefire, E015) in April 2024, and subsequent media reports, confirm Apple matches donations to the following entities 15:

  • Friends of the IDF (FIDF) (E001): Per its own website, this is the “sole organization authorized to collect charitable donations on behalf of the soldiers of the Israel Defense Forces”.15 FIDF boasted of transferring $34.5 million in donations to the IDF in the first weeks following October 7, 2023.61
  • One Israel Fund (E009): Per its mission statement, it “has remained committed to the safety and wellbeing of the nearly 500,000 residents of Judea and Samaria”.15 This is an explicit reference to supporting illegal settlers in the Occupied West Bank.
  • HaYovel Inc. (E002): An organization whose mission statement and public record document its “decades of contribution to illegal settlements within the Occupied Palestinian Territories”.15
  • Jewish National Fund (JNF) (E010): A Haaretz report revealed this organization was “recruited by the Defense Ministry… to purchase hundreds of dunams of private, Palestinian-owned land in the West Bank for settlers”.15
  • IsraelGives (E011): A crowdfunding platform that, according to The Guardian, has allowed U.S. residents to donate millions to “causes including illegal West Bank settlements, paramilitary groups, and Israel Defense Forces (IDF) units”.15

Crucial Insight: After media coverage exposed this program, “Friends of the IDF” (E001) was reportedly removed from the Benevity platform. However, as of December 2024, it was restored.18 This act of restoration removes all plausible deniability. It demonstrates that Apple’s leadership is aware of the nature of the organization and has made a conscious, deliberate decision to re-authorize it for corporate matching.

Funding Table: Benevity Matching Program Complicity

Entity / Source Instrument Amount Date Notes
Friends of the IDF (FIDF) Donation Matching Employee-dependent Directly funds the Israeli military. Apple knowingly restored this entity to the platform.
One Israel Fund Donation Matching Employee-dependent Explicitly funds illegal settlements in “Judea and Samaria.”
HaYovel Inc. Donation Matching Employee-dependent Funds illegal settlements in Occupied Palestinian Territories.
Jewish National Fund (JNF) Donation Matching Employee-dependent Acts as an agent for the Defense Ministry to acquire Palestinian land for settlers.
IsraelGives Donation Matching Employee-dependent Platform documented to fund “paramilitary groups” and “settlement” activities.
Benevity Platform (Enabler) N/A The third-party platform used by Apple to approve and manage its matching program.

Assessment

Apple’s financial exposure is not one of dependency on Israel, but of intentional support for it. The acquisition strategy (Table 1) demonstrates a structural investment, absorbing the Israeli military-tech ecosystem into its own R&D. The donation program (Table 2) demonstrates active, ideological investment, providing direct material support to the IDF and the illegal settlement enterprise. This latter point is the most severe, as it is a direct corporate choice that, according to legal experts from the Center for Constitutional Rights, may constitute “aiding and abet[ting] war crimes”.61

5. Domains of Complicity (Deep Analyses)

Domain 1: Economic & Structural Complicity (The “Startup Nation” Pillar)

Goal: To establish that Apple’s economic presence in Israel is not incidental, but a strategic, structural pillar that provides material support to the Israeli economy and directly benefits from its militarized tech ecosystem.

Evidence & Analysis:

Apple’s complicity in this domain is not a matter of a few isolated contracts, but of total structural integration. The company’s ~2,500-employee R&D operation 7 makes it one of the largest and most prestigious multinational tech employers in Israel. This operation is not a sales office or a low-level support center; it is Apple’s second-largest R&D hub in the world 8, and its strategic importance is non-negotiable.

The development of flagship technologies like the M-series silicon chips 11 and other critical hardware components 10 occurs in its Herzliya and Haifa centers. This means the core performance of Apple’s most profitable and high-margin products—the Mac and iPad lines—is directly dependent on its Israeli engineering teams. This is the definition of a strategic and material economic tie. This deep integration makes Apple a direct contributor to and beneficiary of Israel’s “Startup Nation” model. The tech sector is a primary pillar of the Israeli economy 62, and this sector is inextricably and openly linked to the military.

This link is not abstract. The Israeli military, particularly the elite intelligence Unit 8200 14, functions as the de facto state-funded R&D and training program for the entire tech sector.63 Apple has directly and repeatedly participated in this specific pipeline.

Case Study: PrimeSense (E004): Apple’s 2013 acquisition of PrimeSense for $345 million 12 is the key exhibit. PrimeSense, whose 3D-sensing technology was foundational for Apple’s Face ID 49, was founded by alumni of IDF Intelligence Unit 8200.14

This acquisition reveals a clear, causal chain:

  1. The Israeli state, via the IDF (Unit 8200), invests heavily in training soldiers in elite surveillance, cyberwarfare, and data analysis, often deployed against the Palestinian population.64
  2. These veterans, equipped with state-funded training and experience, found technology startups (e.g., PrimeSense).14
  3. Apple acquires these startups, absorbing the military-trained talent and their surveillance-adjacent technology directly into its corporate R&D structure.

This is a structural pattern of deliberate choice, as mandated by the user query. Apple is not a passive observer; it is an active consumer and funder of this specific military-to-corporate pipeline. It seeks out and pays a premium for the specific engineering and data-analysis skills generated by the Israeli military-intelligence apparatus.

Counter-Arguments & Assessment:

  • Counter-Argument: “Apple is simply hiring the ‘best talent’ and is apolitical.31 It’s not their fault this talent comes from the military.”
  • Assessment: This is disingenuous. The 8200 pipeline is a known and celebrated feature of the Israeli economy, which Israeli leaders and even tech CEOs like Eric Schmidt have praised.65 To participate in it is a political and economic choice. Apple is not a passive observer; it is an active consumer and funder of this specific military-to-corporate pipeline, a pipeline that produces both Apple’s Face ID technology (via PrimeSense) and NSO Group’s Pegasus spyware.14
  • Counter-Argument: “Apple’s R&D hub in Rawabi 28 shows it is balanced and supports Palestinians too.”
  • Assessment: This is the “Rawabi Fig Leaf” (see Section 2). The ~40-to-1 employment ratio (2,500 in Israel vs. 60 in the West Bank) 7 demonstrates this is a token operation for PR purposes, not a meaningful economic counterweight. It is designed to obscure, not offset, the material support provided by the 2,500-employee Israeli hub.

Analytical Assessment: Apple is structurally complicit. Its core business is materially dependent on its Israeli R&D operations, which are, in turn, structurally integrated with and dependent on the talent pipeline of the Israeli military-intelligence apparatus.

Confidence: High.

Named Entities / Evidence Map: E003 (Anobit), E004 (PrimeSense), E013 (Johny Srouji), T002, T003, T004, T005, T010, T011, T019.

Intelligence Gaps:

  • A precise, internal list of all Apple R&D projects currently active in Israel.
  • The exact percentage of Apple-Israel employees who are veterans of specific IDF intelligence units (e.t., 8200, 9900).
  • Internal Apple policies on recruiting from military-intelligence backgrounds.
  • Tax records showing the total amount of corporate taxes paid by Apple to the Israeli state annually.

Domain 2: Direct Ideological & Financial Complicity (Aiding & Abetting)

Goal: To prosecute the case that Apple, as a corporation, provides direct and intentional financial support to the Israeli military and the illegal settlement enterprise, in direct violation of international law and its own human rights policy.

Evidence & Analysis:

This is the most direct and indefensible domain of complicity. The primary vector is Apple’s corporate employee donation matching program, managed via the Benevity platform (E012).56 This is not passive investment or an incidental association. This is an active corporate program where Apple matches employee funds, effectively making a corporate donation. Apple must approve organizations for eligibility on this platform.18 The inclusion of the entities below is a deliberate corporate choice.

1. Funding the IDF: Apple matches donations to Friends of the IDF (FIDF) (E001).15

  • FIDF’s sole purpose, by its own admission, is to support IDF soldiers and units: it is the “sole organization authorized to collect charitable donations on behalf of the soldiers of the… IDF”.15
  • FIDF boasted of transferring $34.5 million to the IDF in the first weeks after October 7, 2023.61
  • By matching funds to FIDF, Apple is directly subsidizing a foreign military. This military is currently under investigation for genocide by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) 56 and its leaders are sought for arrest for war crimes by the International Criminal Court (ICC).56

2. Funding Illegal Settlements: Apple matches donations to multiple 501(c)(3) organizations whose primary mission is to support and expand illegal settlements in the Occupied West Bank, an act that is a clear violation of international law.

  • One Israel Fund (E009): States its commitment to the “safety and wellbeing of the nearly 500,000 residents of Judea and Samaria”.15 This is an explicit, open-faced pro-settlement organization.
  • HaYovel Inc. (E002): Has a documented “decades of contribution to illegal settlements within the Occupied Palestinian Territories”.15
  • Jewish National Fund (JNF) (E010): Implicated in a 2021 Haaretz report for being “recruited by the Defense Ministry… to purchase hundreds of dunams of private, Palestinian-owned land in the West Bank for settlers”.15

3. Evidence of Knowledge and Intent: This is the most damning evidence. The act transforms from potential negligence to conscious, deliberate, and intentional policy.

  • In April 2024, a group of shareholders and employees (E015) published an open letter publicly identifying these organizations on Apple’s platform and demanding their removal.15
  • Following media coverage, “Friends of the IDF” (E001) was reportedly removed from the Benevity portal.
  • However, as of December 2024, it was restored.18
  • This act of restoration removes all plausible deniability. It proves Apple’s leadership is aware of the nature of the organization, aware of the internal and public protest, and made a conscious decision to re-authorize it for corporate matching.

Counter-Arguments & Assessment:

  • Counter-Argument: “Apple is simply matching employee choice. It’s about ‘freedom to donate’ to any 501(c)(3) organization.”
  • Assessment: This argument is false on three counts.
    1. Approval: Apple is not a passive conduit. It approves the list of eligible organizations.18
    2. Legal Liability: As legal experts like Diala Shamas (Center for Constitutional Rights) have stated, the 501(c)(3) status does not provide a legal shield. “Regardless of whether an organisation has nonprofit status, it is illegal to aid and abet war crimes”.61 Legislative efforts like New York’s “Not On Our Dime Act” 55 are specifically designed to challenge this “charity” loophole.
    3. Selectivity: This “freedom” is not extended to employees supporting Palestine (see Domain 3).

Analytical Assessment: This is the strongest and most prosecutable domain of complicity. Apple is not passive. It is an active and knowing financial partner to organizations that directly support the IDF’s military operations and the illegal, violent settlement enterprise. This is a direct, material, and ideological alignment that directly contradicts its own human rights policy.56

Confidence: High.

Named Entities / Evidence Map: E001 (FIDF), E002 (HaYovel), E009 (One Israel Fund), E010 (JNF), E011 (IsraelGives), E012 (Benevity), E015 (Apples4Ceasefire), T016, T017, T018.

Intelligence Gaps:

  • The total dollar amount matched by Apple to E001, E002, E009, E010, and E011 since October 2023.
  • Which Apple executive or committee (e.g., the Audit and Finance Committee, E014) is responsible for approving and restoring organizations to the Benevity platform.
  • Apple’s internal legal review, if any, of these organizations’ compliance with its Human Rights Policy.
  • A full list of all 501(c)(3) organizations related to Israel/Palestine that Apple has denied matching for.

Domain 3: Corporate Policy vs. Internal Suppression (Systemic Anti-Palestinian Bias)

Goal: To demonstrate that Apple’s pro-Israel alignment is not just an external policy, but is internally enforced through systemic anti-Palestinian bias, retaliation, and the selective application of corporate policy.

Evidence & Analysis:

Apple’s “Commitment to Human Rights” 19 and “Business Conduct Policy” 41 are not applied universally. When it comes to the issue of Palestine, they are weaponized to enforce a specific, one-sided corporate ideology.

1. One-Sided Leadership: On October 9, 2023, CEO Tim Cook (E016) issued a statement on the “loss of innocent Israeli lives”.20 He and Apple’s leadership have remained silent on the documented deaths of tens of thousands of Palestinians, despite numerous employee and shareholder letters (e.g., Apples4Ceasefire, E015) begging them to “end their silence” and acknowledge Palestinian suffering.20 This sets a clear, top-down corporate tone: Israeli lives are officially grievable; Palestinian lives are not.

2. Retaliation & “Wrongful Termination”: Apple has used its “Business Conduct Policy” 41 as a pretext to silence pro-Palestinian speech.

  • Case Study: Madly Espinoza (E017): A Palestinian-American employee at a Chicago Apple Store, was fired on March 6, 2024.23 Her documented offense: wearing a keffiyeh and “Save Gaza” / watermelon bracelets.23
  • Crucially, Espinoza had previously asked managers if wearing the keffiyeh was permissible and was told “yes, as long as it wasn’t covering my Apple logo”.22
  • Weeks later, management reversed this, issued a disciplinary document, and terminated her. She was verbally told her actions were “too political” and created a “harmful environment”.22
  • Pattern: The “Apples4Ceasefire” (E015) open letter confirms this is a pattern, alleging multiple “wrongful terminations” and “retaliatory firings” for employees who “dared to express support of the Palestinian people in the form of kaffiyehs, pins, bracelets, or clothing”.20 Another Apple manager reported being told by HR that they were “not allowed to wear [their] cultural garment” (the keffiyeh) due to the “political stance” it addresses.45

3. Systemic Suppression: In November 2023, Apple leadership “paused” and effectively shut down the internal “Muslims@Apple” Slack channel.22 This was the primary channel for Muslim and Arab employees to communicate and support each other. This act was described by employee groups as a collective punishment 69 and the silencing of an official “Diversity Network Association” (DNA) 69, while other DNA groups remained open.43

Counter-Arguments & Assessment:

  • Counter-Argument: “Apple’s policy 72 requires a neutral, customer-facing environment. Political symbols are disruptive.”
  • Assessment: This is demonstrably false through Apple’s own actions as detailed in Domain 2. The company permits and funds the most extreme political expression—direct financial support for a foreign military (FIDF)—through its official corporate donation platform. It only prohibits the expression of Palestinian identity and human rights, which it deems “too political”.22 The policy is applied selectively to enforce a specific political ideology.

Analytical Assessment: The contradiction is the policy. Apple operates a two-tiered system that is fundamentally anti-Palestinian:

  • Tier 1 (Approved): Pro-Israel ideology. Manifests as corporate donation matching for the IDF and illegal settlements.17
  • Tier 2 (Prohibited): Pro-Palestine solidarity. Manifests as a “cultural garment” 45 or a bracelet 23, which are grounds for termination.

This internal regime of active suppression and retaliation 21 reveals the company’s true ideological alignment, rendering its public Human Rights Policy 19 a “marketing” document.43

Confidence: High.

Named Entities / Evidence Map: E015 (Apples4Ceasefire), E016 (Tim Cook), E017 (Madly Espinoza), T012, T013, T014, T015.

Intelligence Gaps:

  • A full list of all employees “wrongfully terminated” or disciplined for pro-Palestine expression since October 2023.
  • Internal HR memos, “Business Conduct” guidance, or “talking points” distributed to managers post-Oct. 7.
  • Communications from Apple’s legal or HR departments regarding the (E017) Madly Espinoza case.
  • Transcripts or summaries of the internal WebEx chats held with the “Muslims@Apple” community.43

Domain 4: Military & Intelligence Links (The “NSO Paradox” and Direct Use Assessment)

Goal: To fairly assess (1) the indirect complicity represented by Apple’s contradictory stance on Israeli spyware and (2. Absence of evidence for direct use of Apple technology in IDF surveillance systems.

Evidence & Analysis (Indirect Complicity):

Apple’s relationship with the Israeli surveillance state is sophisticated. It is defined by a “paradox” that, upon inspection, reveals a coherent brand-defense strategy.

  • The “NSO Paradox”: In November 2021, Apple filed a major lawsuit against Israel’s NSO Group (E018) to “curb the abuse of state-sponsored spyware”.26 NSO Group, the creator of the Pegasus spyware 73, is a product of the same Unit 8200 ecosystem as many other Israeli tech firms.14
  • This lawsuit is not an anti-occupation or anti-Israel stance. It is a brand-defense and product-security action. NSO’s Pegasus spyware 73 exploits Apple’s iOS, which is a direct, existential threat to Apple’s core brand promise of “privacy”.26
  • Apple’s strategy is therefore paradoxical but coherent:
    1. FIGHT: Publicly sue “mercenary spyware” firms (NSO) that target its OS and damage its brand.26
    2. INTEGRATE: Quietly acquire “surveillance-adjacent” firms (PrimeSense, RealFace) 12 from the same military-intelligence pipeline to build its OS (e.g., Face ID).
    3. FUND: Financially support the military (FIDF) 17 that spawns this entire ecosystem.

This strategy allows Apple to appear as a champion of human rights (fighting NSO) while simultaneously being a pillar of the very military-tech ecosystem that produces NSO.

Evidence & Analysis (Direct Use Assessment):

Per the mandate to “not overstate weak links,” a rigorous search was conducted for evidence of Apple’s proprietary technology being directly used by the Israeli military for surveillance in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.

Human rights reports (Amnesty, HRW) and media investigations have documented the IDF’s use of mass surveillance and facial recognition in the West Bank and Gaza. Systems include “Blue Wolf” (a gamified app for “capturing” Palestinian faces) 74, “Red Wolf” (automated checkpoint FR) 76, and AI targeting systems like “Lavender” and “The Gospel”.80

This investigation found no evidence that Apple’s proprietary technology (e.g., its Face ID algorithms or hardware) is being directly licensed or provided to the Israeli military for use in these systems.

Reports from Amnesty International 78, The New York Times 82, and other sources on these systems name other companies:

  • Hikvision (Chinese) (CCTV cameras in Hebron) 78
  • TKH Security (Dutch) (CCTV cameras in Hebron) 78
  • Google (via Google Photos, used to build an FR database) 82
  • Amazon & Google (Project Nimbus cloud infrastructure) 83
  • Microsoft (Azure cloud for Unit 8200) 64

Furthermore, the “Who Profits” report “The Role of Big Tech in the Israeli Occupation Economy” 89 profiles Microsoft, Cisco, IBM, and Dell, but does not include a profile for Apple.89

Analytical Assessment: Apple’s complicity is not (at present) comparable to Google/Amazon’s (Project Nimbus) or Microsoft’s (Azure for Unit 8200). Its complicity is economic (R&D hub), structural (8200 pipeline), and financial-ideological (FIDF/settlement donations). The absence of evidence for direct military-technical complicity must be noted for a credible, “prosecutorial” report that rests on maximal accuracy.

Confidence (for indirect structural links): High.

Confidence (for direct tech use in IDF systems): Low / Inconclusive.

Named Entities / Evidence Map: E004 (PrimeSense), E018 (NSO Group), T003, T009.

Intelligence Gaps:

  • Any clauses in Apple’s Israeli R&D agreements that compel cooperation with the Israeli Ministry of Defense.
  • Any Israeli government requests for customer data related to the OPT, and Apple’s response (Apple’s transparency report for Israel is vague).90
  • Internal communications regarding the NSO lawsuit vs. the PrimeSense acquisition.
  • Any internal ethics review of acquiring surveillance-adjacent technology (RealFace, PrimeSense) from a military-intelligence pipeline.

6. Network of Influence

Purpose: To reveal the key actors and organizations that form the ecosystem connecting Apple to the Israeli state, its military, and the settlement enterprise.

Entity Table:

Name Type Role / Link
Friends of the IDF (FIDF) Non-Profit Receives matching corporate donations from Apple; funds IDF units.
HaYovel Inc. Non-Profit Receives matching corporate donations from Apple; funds illegal settlements.
Anobit Acquired Co. First major Israeli acquisition; became Apple R&D core.
PrimeSense Acquired Co. Key Israeli acquisition (Face ID); founded by Unit 8200 alumni.
One Israel Fund Non-Profit Receives matching corporate donations from Apple; funds illegal settlements.
Benevity Platform Third-party platform used by Apple to approve and process matching donations.
Johny Srouji Apple Exec SVP, Hardware Technologies. Israeli Arab; architect of Apple’s Israeli R&D presence and face of Rawabi project.
Ronald D. Sugar Apple Exec Board of Directors; Chair, Audit Committee. Former CEO, Northrop Grumman.
Apples4Ceasefire Org (Internal) Employee/shareholder group pressuring Apple to stop complicity.
Tim Cook Apple Exec CEO. Author of one-sided Oct. 9 statement; target of employee letters.
Madly Espinoza Fmr. Employee Palestinian-American fired for wearing keffiyeh.
NSO Group Corporation Israeli spyware firm (Unit 8200 ecosystem); Sued by Apple.
Aharon Aharon Fmr. Apple Exec Former General Manager of Apple Israel. Left Apple to become CEO of the Israel Innovation Authority (state body).

Profiles of Key Actors:

E014 – Ronald D. Sugar (The MIC Governor): Sugar’s position on Apple’s board 5, and specifically his role as Chair of the Audit and Finance Committee 6, forms a profound structural link to the U.S. military-industrial complex. He is the former Chairman and CEO (2003-2010) of Northrop Grumman 29, a primary U.S. defense contractor and major supplier to the IDF. His presence normalizes and aligns Apple’s highest level of governance with the U.S. defense establishment. This creates an environment where deep, structural partnerships with Israel (a key U.S. defense partner) and the active suppression of anti-war dissent (Domain 3) are considered “sound” business practice and risk management, not a human rights violation.

E013 – Johny Srouji (The Architect & The Shield): Srouji, an Israeli Arab from Haifa 8, is Apple’s Senior VP of Hardware Technologies.10 He is the internal champion responsible for building Apple’s Israeli R&D hub into its global “second-largest”.8 His role is twofold: 1) Architect: He successfully embedded Apple’s core technology (M-Chips) in Israel 11, making the company structurally dependent on its Israeli operations. 2) Shield: He is the public face of the Rawabi project 28, using his minority identity as a “poster child” for co-existence to provide a PR “fig leaf” (see Section 2) that masks the ~40-to-1 employment imbalance and the deep links to the military-tech ecosystem.

E019 – Aharon Aharon (The State Revolving Door): Aharon’s career path is a “revolving door” that demonstrates the fusion of Apple and the Israeli state-tech apparatus. He served as VP of Hardware Technologies and General Manager of Apple Israel.92 He left this senior Apple role to become the CEO of the Israel Innovation Authority 92, the core state body (formerly the Chief Scientist’s Office) responsible for nurturing the entire Israeli tech ecosystem.92 This confirms Apple is not just in this ecosystem; its leadership is interchangeable with the managers of the Israeli state-tech apparatus.

E001 & E009 (FIDF & One Israel Fund) (The Financial Conduits): These are not “charities” in the neutral sense. They are ideological instruments. FIDF (E001) is a conduit for tax-deductible U.S. funds to directly support a foreign military.15 One Israel Fund (E009) is a conduit for tax-deductible U.S. funds to directly support the illegal settlement enterprise.15 By approving these for its corporate matching program 17, Apple becomes a co-funder of both the military and the settlements, laundering this support through a U.S. “non-profit” wrapper.

7. Sources & Verification Methodology

Methods: This report was compiled using Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT) methodologies. Data was gathered from publicly available corporate disclosures (e.g., Apple’s leadership 5 and human rights policies 19), SEC filings 4, corporate-run newsrooms 26, and official legal/privacy disclosures.1 This primary-source corporate data was then cross-referenced and “prosecuted” against investigative journalism 7, reports from human rights organizations (Amnesty International 78, Center for Constitutional Rights 55, Who Profits 89), and letters from internal employee and shareholder groups (Apples4Ceasefire 15).

Verification: The report’s core findings rely on corroboration and pattern analysis to meet the user’s “rigorous and justified” standard.

  • Donation Matching: The claim of “funding the IDF” 17 is not based on a single source but is corroborated by multiple, independent open letters 15 and subsequent journalism.18 The key verification point is the report of restoration 18, which proves corporate intent.
  • Internal Suppression: The claim of “anti-Palestinian bias” is verified by cross-referencing multiple, independent employee reports of a “chilling effect” 21, the specific, named case of Madly Espinoza 22, and the collective report of the “Muslims@Apple” channel shutdown.22
  • Military Pipeline: The “Unit 8200” link 14 is verified by explicitly linking a specific Apple acquisition, PrimeSense (E004), to a public list of companies founded by alumni of that unit.14

Analytical Rationale: The analytical inferences in this report are drawn by identifying the systemic contradictions between Apple’s public-facing brand (privacy, human rights, “apolitical” business) and its deliberate corporate choices. These choices include strategic acquisitions from military units, strategic R&D dependence, direct funding of the IDF and settlement enterprise, and the internal suppression of dissent. The report concludes that Apple’s complicity is not accidental, but a multi-layered, intentional, and structural strategy. This strategy prioritizes its geopolitical alignment with the U.S. military-industrial complex and its deep economic integration with Israel above its stated human rights policies and the rights of its own employees.

Works cited

  1. Legal – Privacy Policy Affiliated Company – Apple, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/affiliated-company/
  2. Apple Inc. – Wikipedia, accessed November 11, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc.
  3. Apple Park – Wikipedia, accessed November 11, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Park
  4. Form 10-K – SEC.gov, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/320193/000032019318000145/a10-k20189292018.htm
  5. Apple Leadership, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/leadership/
  6. Leadership and Governance – Apple Investor Relations, accessed November 11, 2025, https://investor.apple.com/leadership-and-governance/
  7. How Israeli ingenuity became the secret engine behind Apple’s most advanced product, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.ynetnews.com/business/article/bjqvbav7ex
  8. Tim Cook: Apple’s Herzliya R&D center second-largest in world | The Times of Israel, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.timesofisrael.com/apples-herzliya-rd-center-now-second-largest-in-world/
  9. Israeli Tech: Apple Establishes a Stronger Presence in Israel, accessed November 11, 2025, https://yucommentator.org/2015/03/israeli-tech-apple-establishes-a-stronger-presence-in-israel/
  10. Apple’s R&D center in Israel grew to about 800 employees – Techtime News, accessed November 11, 2025, https://techtime.news/2016/05/15/apple/
  11. Apple expands R&D operations in Israel and Palestine, with former focused on Mac chips, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.phonearena.com/news/apple-opens-new-centre-in-israel-mac-chips_id141570
  12. Apple Buys Facial Recognition Co. RealFace – NoCamels, accessed November 11, 2025, https://nocamels.com/2017/02/apple-buys-facial-recognition-co-realface/
  13. Apple secretly acquired Israeli photography startup Camerai | Ctech, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3845818,00.html
  14. Unit 8200 – Wikipedia, accessed November 11, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_8200
  15. Apple Cease Funding for Illegal Settlements and Israeli Military – Open Letter, accessed November 11, 2025, https://openletter.earth/de/apple-cease-funding-for-illegal-settlements-and-israeli-military-d5e63fa8?limit=0
  16. Apple Cease Funding for Illegal Settlements and Israeli Military, accessed November 11, 2025, https://openletter.earth/apple-cease-funding-for-illegal-settlements-and-israeli-military-d5e63fa8
  17. These Billionaires Subsidize the Israeli Military Through a US Nonprofit | Truthout, accessed November 11, 2025, https://truthout.org/articles/these-billionaires-subsidize-the-israeli-military-through-a-us-nonprofit/
  18. Protesters shut down Apple store on Black Friday for Palestine and Congo – Real Change, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.realchangenews.org/news/2024/12/05/protesters-shut-down-apple-store-black-friday-palestine-and-congo
  19. Our Commitment to Human Rights – Apple, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/compliance/pdfs/Apple-Human-Rights-Policy.pdf
  20. Apple employees urge the company to end silence on Palestine …, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/apple-employees-urge-the-company-to-end-silence-on-palestine/
  21. Apple workers are speaking up in solidarity with Palestine | Mashable, accessed November 11, 2025, https://mashable.com/article/apple-employees-palestine-tim-cook-open-letter
  22. Apple store employees say coworkers were disciplined for supporting Palestinians, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/apple-store-employees-say-coworkers-were-disciplined-for-supporting-palestinians/
  23. Apple punishes workers for expressing Palestinian identity, solidarity – YouTube, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmqjqp3JeX0
  24. 300 employees accuse Apple of “wrongfully terminating” and punishing workers for expressing pro-Palestine views | Talent | HR Grapevine USA, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.hrgrapevine.com/us/content/article/2024-04-04-300-employees-accuse-apple-of-wrongfully-terminating-workers-for-expressing-pro-palestine-views
  25. Apple punishes workers for expressing Palestinian identity, solidarity – Palestine in America, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.palestineinamerica.com/blog/apple-punishes-workers-for-expressing-palestinian-identity-solidarity
  26. Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored spyware, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/11/apple-sues-nso-group-to-curb-the-abuse-of-state-sponsored-spyware/
  27. Apple Expands In Israel Opening Development Center In Jerusalem – i24NEWS, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/israel/technology-science/1659028317-israel-apple-opens-development-center-in-jerusalem
  28. Apple expanding R&D hub in Palestinian Authority | Ctech, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/bypitho59
  29. Ronald Sugar – Wikipedia, accessed November 11, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_Sugar
  30. Dean’s Executive Board Member | Ronald D. Sugar | UCLA Samueli School Of Engineering, accessed November 11, 2025, https://samueli.ucla.edu/deb_sugar/
  31. Does Apple Support Israel? -Look at the Tech Giant’s Relationship with Israel – The Brussels Morning Newspaper, accessed November 11, 2025, https://brusselsmorning.com/does-apple-support-israel-look-at-the-tech-giants-relationship-with-israel/62654/
  32. How the Largest Companies Reacted to the Israel-Hamas War – Ragan Consulting Group, accessed November 11, 2025, https://raganconsulting.com/ceo-reaction-israel-hamas-war-public-relations/
  33. Contact Tim Cook – Apples4Ceasefire, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apples4ceasefire.com/contact-tim
  34. Ronald D. Sugar Joins Apple’s Board of Directors, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/11/17Ronald-D-Sugar-Joins-Apples-Board-of-Directors/
  35. Apple’s history and development in Israel | The Jerusalem Post, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.jpost.com/business/apples-history-and-development-in-israel-392387
  36. Apple onboards over 60 Palestinian engineers, looks to grow | The Jerusalem Post, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.jpost.com/business-and-innovation/all-news/article-710800
  37. Apple To Expand Palestinian R&D Center In Rawabi – NoCamels, accessed November 11, 2025, https://nocamels.com/2022/07/apple-palestinian-rawabi/
  38. Apple To Expand R&D Center In Palestinian City Of Rawabi – i24NEWS, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/middle-east/technology-science/1656488443-apple-to-expand-r-d-center-in-palestinian-city-of-rawabi
  39. Apple to expand Palestinian R&D center in Rawabi – JNS.org, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.jns.org/apple-to-expand-palestinian-rd-center-in-rawabi/
  40. Apple plans to expand its R&D hub in Rawabi – AppleInsider, accessed November 11, 2025, https://appleinsider.com/articles/22/06/29/apple-plans-to-expand-its-rd-hub-in-rawabi
  41. Ethics and Compliance – Policies – Apple, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/compliance/policies/
  42. Apple causes International Incident – UK Lawyers for Israel, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.uklfi.com/apple-causes-international-incident
  43. Rotten to the Core: How the Gaza genocide has revealed anti-Palestinian racism at Apple, accessed November 11, 2025, https://mondoweiss.net/2024/06/rotten-to-the-core-how-the-gaza-genocide-has-revealed-anti-palestinian-racism-at-apple/
  44. Protesters worldwide claim that Apple is complicit in human rights violations in the DRC and Gaza; co. did not respond, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/protesters-apple-complicit-human-rights-violations-drc-and-gaza/
  45. Apple Accused of Punishing Employees for Showing Palestinian Support – PCMag, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.pcmag.com/news/apple-accused-of-punishing-employees-for-showing-palestinian-support
  46. Apple Corporation Highlights Israel – The Ettinger Report, accessed November 11, 2025, https://theettingerreport.com/apple-corporation-highlights-israel/
  47. Anobit – Wikipedia, accessed November 11, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anobit
  48. Apple quietly acquires Israeli 3D avatar startup TrueMeeting | Ctech, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/hkb0cyirxx
  49. Why did Apple buy PrimeSense? For a key technology it’ll deploy within a year, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/nov/25/why-did-apple-buy-primesense-for-a-key-technology-itll-deploy-within-a-year
  50. Apple buys under-the-radar camera-technology company LinX – ISRAEL21c, accessed November 11, 2025, https://israel21c.org/apple-buys-under-the-radar-camera-technology-company-linx/
  51. Apple (Computing/Logistics) – The Mapping Project, accessed November 11, 2025, https://mapliberation.org/dev/map_js/?entities=Apple
  52. Apple CEO Tim Cook Will Inaugurate Israel’s New Headquarters – The Forward, accessed November 11, 2025, https://forward.com/fast-forward/214685/apple-ceo-tim-cook-will-inaugurate-israels-new-hea/
  53. The Israel High Tech & Investment Report, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.ishitech.co.il/From.HTML
  54. Apple said to have secretively bought Israel’s Camerai, a maker of camera tech, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-giant-apple-reportedly-bought-israels-camerai-a-maker-of-camera-tech/
  55. Apple matches worker donations to IDF and illegal settlements, employees allege, accessed November 11, 2025, https://ccrjustice.org/home/press-center/ccr-news/apple-matches-worker-donations-idf-and-illegal-settlements-employees
  56. Apple under fire for matching employee donations to IDF and illegal settlements, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240612-apple-under-fire-for-matching-employee-donations-to-idf-and-illegal-settlements/
  57. Top News from Israel & Palestine: June 14-21, 2024 – Foundation for Middle East Peace, accessed November 11, 2025, https://fmep.org/resource/top-news-from-israel-palestine-june-14-21-2024/
  58. Apple under fire for matching employee donations to IDF and illegal settlements, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.tbsnews.net/worldbiz/usa/apple-under-fire-matching-employee-donations-idf-and-illegal-settlements-879791
  59. Anger over Apple scheme ‘encouraging staff’ to donate to Israel – The New Arab, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.newarab.com/news/anger-over-apple-scheme-encouraging-staff-donate-israel
  60. Employees accuse Apple of donating to groups funding West Bank settlements, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/employees-accuse-apple-donating-groups-funding-west-bank-settlements
  61. Apple sending employee donations to Israeli army, illegal settlers: report – TRT World, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.trtworld.com/article/18173038
  62. No Tech for Oppression, Apartheid or Genocide | BDS Movement, accessed November 11, 2025, https://bdsmovement.net/no-tech-oppression-apartheid-or-genocide
  63. Startup Soldiers: From the IDF to High-Tech Success, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/our-soldiers/startup-soldiers-from-the-idf-to-high-tech-success/
  64. Microsoft’s Crackdown on Unit 8200 Reveals Tech’s Intermediary Role – Lawfare, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/microsoft-s-crackdown-on-unit-8200-reveals-tech-s-intermediary-role
  65. The deep ties between Google and the Israeli military – Tech for Palestine, accessed November 11, 2025, https://updates.techforpalestine.org/the-deep-ties-between-google-and-the-israeli-military/
  66. How Israeli spy veterans are shaping US big tech | The Take – YouTube, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QL4aKiDnE6E
  67. ‘A million calls an hour’: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians – The Guardian, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/06/microsoft-israeli-military-palestinian-phone-calls-cloud
  68. Israeli firm accused of creating iPhone spyware | Surveillance – The Guardian, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/aug/26/israeli-firm-accused-of-creating-iphone-spyware
  69. Apple Must End Direct Complicity in Apartheid and Genocide – Open Letter, accessed November 11, 2025, https://openletter.earth/apple-must-end-direct-complicity-in-apartheid-and-genocide-a1c37c20
  70. Guide to BDS Boycott & Pressure Corporate Priority Targeting, accessed November 11, 2025, https://bdsmovement.net/Guide-to-BDS-Boycott
  71. Apple accused of giving worker donations to Israeli soldiers, settlements – The Cradle, accessed November 11, 2025, https://thecradle.co/articles-id/25404
  72. Apple Business Conduct Policy, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/compliance/pdfs/Business-Conduct-Policy.pdf
  73. Devices of Palestinian Human Rights Defenders Hacked with NSO Group’s Pegasus Spyware – Amnesty International, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/research/2021/11/devices-of-palestinian-human-rights-defenders-hacked-with-nso-groups-pegasus-spyware-2/
  74. Algorithmic State Violence: Automated Surveillance and Palestinian Dispossession in Hebron’s Old City – Cambridge University Press & Assessment, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/80B9C5192057ACEA17089E488CFC1486/S0020743823000879a.pdf/algorithmic_state_violence_automated_surveillance_and_palestinian_dispossession_in_hebrons_old_city.pdf
  75. How Israel uses facial-recognition systems in Gaza and beyond – The Guardian, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2024/apr/19/idf-facial-recognition-surveillance-palestinians
  76. Algorithmic State Violence: Automated Surveillance and Palestinian Dispossession in Hebron’s Old City | International Journal of Middle East Studies | Cambridge Core, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-middle-east-studies/article/algorithmic-state-violence-automated-surveillance-and-palestinian-dispossession-in-hebrons-old-city/80B9C5192057ACEA17089E488CFC1486
  77. ‘The system learns to recognize you’: Amnesty calls out automated apartheid, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.972mag.com/amnesty-automated-apartheid-mahmoudi/
  78. Israeli authorities using facial recognition to entrench apartheid, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2023/05/israel-opt-israeli-authorities-are-using-facial-recognition-technology-to-entrench-apartheid/
  79. Israel increasingly using facial recognition to track Palestinians – Amnesty, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-increasingly-using-facial-recognition-to-track-palestinians-amnesty/
  80. Questions and Answers: Israeli Military’s Use of Digital Tools in Gaza | Human Rights Watch, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/09/10/questions-and-answers-israeli-militarys-use-digital-tools-gaza
  81. Gaza: Israeli Military’s Digital Tools Risk Civilian Harm – Human Rights Watch, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/09/10/gaza-israeli-militarys-digital-tools-risk-civilian-harm
  82. Military Use of Biometrics Series – Israel’s Use of AI-DSS and Facial Recognition Technology: The Erosion of Civilian Protection in Gaza – Lieber Institute, accessed November 11, 2025, https://lieber.westpoint.edu/israels-use-ai-dss-facial-recognition-technology-erosion-civilian-protection-gaza/
  83. Tech Cooperation: This Is How Apple and Google Stand Alongside ‘Israel’, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.alestiklal.net/en/article/tech-cooperation-this-is-how-apple-and-google-stand-alongside-israel
  84. Big Tech’s bind with military and intelligence agencies | Privacy International, accessed November 11, 2025, https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/5683/big-techs-bind-military-and-intelligence-agencies
  85. ‘Order from Amazon’: Tech giants storing mass data for Israel’s war – +972 Magazine, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.972mag.com/cloud-israeli-army-gaza-amazon-google-microsoft/
  86. Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its technology in mass surveillance of Palestinians – The Guardian, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/sep/25/microsoft-blocks-israels-use-of-its-technology-in-mass-surveillance-of-palestinians
  87. The Azure Unit 8200 Dragnet: Cloud, Code & Complicity Inside Microsoft & Israeli Military Intelligence’s Mass Palestinian Surveillance Machine – Apple Podcasts, accessed November 11, 2025, https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-azure-unit-8200-dragnet-cloud-code-complicity/id1656552317?i=1000723073784
  88. Resistance to digital colonialism in Palestine – Bianet, accessed November 11, 2025, https://bianet.org/yazi/resistance-to-digital-colonialism-in-palestine-313213
  89. The Israeli Occupation Industry – The Role of Big Tech … – Who Profits, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.whoprofits.org/publications/report/164?the-role-of-big-tech-in-the-israeli-occupation-economy
  90. Privacy – Government Information Requests – Apple (IS), accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/il.html
  91. Apple boosts iPhone security after Israeli spyware reveals startling weaknesses, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.timesofisrael.com/apple-boosts-iphone-security-after-israeli-spyware-reveals-startling-weaknesses/
  92. Interview Of The Week: Aharon Aharon – The Innovator, accessed November 11, 2025, https://theinnovator.news/2019-07-23_interview-of-the-week-aharon-aharon-2648ae80da11/
  93. Aharon Aharon – Kenes Exhibitions, accessed November 11, 2025, https://kenes-exhibitions.com/agritech/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Aharon-Aharon-Bio.pdf
  94. Aharon Aharon – Research Money, accessed November 11, 2025, https://researchmoneyinc.com/article/aharon-aharon
  95. Aharon Aharon Archives – English Innovation Site, accessed November 11, 2025, https://innovationisrael.org.il/en/writer/aharon-aharon/
  96. Innovation Authority CEO Aharon Aharon to step down for ‘next challenges’, accessed November 11, 2025, https://www.timesofisrael.com/innovation-authority-ceo-aharon-aharon-to-step-down-for-next-challenges/
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News & Articles