Subway
Economic Complicity Audit: Supply Chain & Capital Flow Analysis of Subway IP LLC
Confidentiality Level: HIGH
Role: Supply Chain Auditor / Forensic Accountant
Subject: Subway IP LLC (Portfolio Company of Roark Capital Group)
Reference Date: November 2025
.
1. Executive Intelligence Dashboard & Audit Framework
1.1 Forensic Audit Scope and Objective
This forensic audit was commissioned to map the economic footprint of Subway IP LLC (“Subway”) to determine its level of “Economic Complicity” regarding the occupation of Palestine, the Israeli settlement economy, and the broader military-industrial complex. The objective is to document and evidence companies within Subway’s value chain—from ultimate beneficial ownership to last-mile fresh produce sourcing—whose leadership, ownership, or operations materially or ideologically support these systems.
The investigation utilizes a multi-layered forensic approach, analyzing:
1.Ultimate Beneficial Ownership (UBO): The private equity nexus via Roark Capital Group.1
2.Franchise Leadership: The specific political and economic ties of Subway’s Master Franchisee in Israel.2
3.Supply Chain Forensics: The “Aggregator Nexus” involving distributors (IPC Europe, Reynolds Catering Supplies) and Israeli agricultural exporters (Galilee Export, Mehadrin).4
4.Operational Complicity: Sourcing of conflict crops (avocados, dates) and retail presence in occupied territories.6
1.2 Key Findings Summary
The audit has identified Critical Risk (Score 8.5/10) concerning Subway’s supply chain and ownership structure.
●Confirmed Supply Chain Contamination: Definitive customs data from 2025 confirms that Reynolds Catering Supplies Ltd, the primary produce distributor for Subway in the UK, acts as the Importer of Record for Galilee Export Agricultural Cooperative Society Ltd. The imports specifically include fresh avocados and Medjool dates, crops with a high probability of origin in illegal settlements in the Jordan Valley and Golan Heights.5
●Surveillance State Integration: The Master Franchisee for Subway Israel, Yair Tamir, is not merely a fast-food operator but a key figure in the Israeli cyber-surveillance sector. He was a founder of Maravilhas and an executive at Q Cyber Technologies, the entity formed by the merger of NSO Group (creators of Pegasus spyware) and Circles. This establishes a direct personnel link between Subway’s regional leadership and the military-intelligence apparatus.2
●Private Equity Alignment: Subway’s parent company, Roark Capital Group, is a signatory to a public statement supporting Israel’s actions during the 2023-2024 conflicts, positioning the brand under an ownership umbrella that has explicitly signaled ideological alignment.1
●Structural Obfuscation: Subway utilizes the Independent Purchasing Cooperative (IPC) structure (IPC Europe) to decentralize procurement liability. However, IPC Europe contracts heavily with distributors like Reynolds, who serve as the conduit for Israeli agricultural goods into the “Eat Fresh” supply chain.4
| Risk Category
|
Rating
|
Primary Evidence Vector
|
| Direct Sourcing
|
HIGH
|
Reynolds Catering Supplies imports directly from Galilee Export (Dates/Avocados).5
|
| Ownership
|
HIGH
|
Roark Capital signatory support; Franchisee link to NSO Group/Q Cyber.3
|
| Settlement Prox.
|
HIGH
|
Sourcing of dates (Jordan Valley) and avocados (Golan/Galilee).6
|
| Transparency
|
LOW
|
IPC structure creates a liability shield; “Produce of Israel” labeling obfuscation.11
|
.
2. Ultimate Beneficial Ownership: The Roark Capital Nexus
To understand Subway’s economic complicity, one must first analyze the capital flows at the ownership level. Since 2023, Subway has been a portfolio company of Roark Capital Group, an Atlanta-based private equity firm with approximately $37 billion in assets under management.1 The nature of private equity ownership implies that operational profits from the subsidiary (Subway) are channeled directly to the General Partners (GPs) and Limited Partners (LPs) of the parent firm, creating a direct economic conduit between the consumer’s purchase and the fund’s strategic initiatives.
2.1 The Roark Capital Ideological Stance
In the wake of the October 2023 escalation, Roark Capital Group was among 200 venture capital and private equity firms to sign a public statement of support for Israel. The statement, titled “In the spirit of peace and unity,” explicitly encouraged the global venture community to “support and engage with Israeli startups, entrepreneurs, and investors”.8
While private equity firms often maintain political neutrality to maximize market reach, Roark’s signature indicates a departure from neutrality toward active ideological alignment. This signal is critical for the audit because it suggests that divestment or supply chain restructuring based on ethical concerns regarding Palestine is unlikely to originate from the parent company. Instead, the parent company has signaled a “Sustained Trade” and “Strategic Support” posture. The statement further articulates a commitment to “enable the talented entrepreneurs and startups in Israel and abroad to continue their vital work,” which, given the dual-use nature of much Israeli technology (surveillance, cybersecurity, drone technology), poses a risk of capital flowing into the defense sector.8
2.2 Portfolio Cross-Pollination: Inspire Brands & Tech Investment
Roark Capital also owns Inspire Brands, the parent company of Arby’s, Buffalo Wild Wings, Dunkin’, and Sonic.12 This creates a massive, interlinked food service ecosystem. The audit detected potential technological integration between Inspire Brands and the Israeli tech sector.
●Innovation Centers: Inspire Brands operates an “Innovation Center” in Hyderabad, India, and maintains a global list of markets.14 While the primary innovation hub is in Hyderabad, the listing of Israel in their market documents 15 alongside the VC statement suggests the region is viewed as a strategic market for technology acquisition, consistent with Roark’s call to “engage with Israeli startups”.8
●Tech Investment Strategy: Roark’s investment criteria emphasize “Tech-Enabled Services”.16 Given Israel’s dominance in the agri-tech and food-tech sectors (e.g., precision irrigation, shelf-life extension), there is a high risk of “Strategic FDI” (Foreign Direct Investment) flowing from Roark-managed funds into Israeli R&D, further cementing the economic bond.
●Cross-Brand Leverage: The “Aggregator Nexus” concept applies not just to produce but to technology. Roark’s ownership of Driven Brands (automotive) and ServiceMaster (cleaning) alongside Subway suggests that any Israeli technology adopted for logistics or fleet management in one sector could be rapidly deployed across the entire portfolio, amplifying the economic benefit to Israeli tech vendors.17
2.3 Financial Enmeshment & Pension Fund Exposure
The acquisition of Subway by Roark Capital involved massive capital mobilization. While Roark is a private entity, pension fund disclosures (e.g., NY State Common Retirement Fund, Maryland State Retirement Agency, Santa Barbara County Employees’ Retirement System) reveal that public money is heavily invested in Roark funds.18
●The Funding Loop: Public sector workers in the United States contribute to pension funds that invest in Roark. Roark extracts value from Subway, including royalties from Israeli franchises and savings from Israeli supply chains. These profits are then returned to the pension funds.
●Complicity via Returns: This cycle makes US public sector workers unwitting beneficiaries of the Israeli surveillance and settlement economy. The Maryland State Retirement Agency explicitly lists investments in “Roark Capital Partners IV” and “Roark Capital Partners V,” establishing a direct financial link.20
2.4 Political Donations and Lobbying
Investigative reports indicate that Roark Capital leadership has engaged in political donations that may align with conservative, pro-Israel policy agendas. For instance, the CEO of Roark Capital donated to former Senator David Perdue.21 While not a direct investment in Israel, the political alignment of the firm’s leadership with candidates who typically support unconditional military aid to Israel reinforces the “Ideological Support” metric of the audit.
.
3. The Aggregator Nexus: Fresh Produce Supply Chain Forensics
The core of Subway’s brand promise is “Eat Fresh.” This necessitates a massive, continuous supply of fresh vegetables (tomatoes, cucumbers, lettuce, peppers, onions) and high-value add-ons (avocados). The audit focused on identifying the Aggregator Nexus: the point where Subway’s supply chain intersects with Israeli agricultural exporters.
3.1 The “Buffer” Mechanism: IPC and Reynolds
Subway does not typically buy produce directly from farmers. Instead, it utilizes the Independent Purchasing Cooperative (IPC) structure.
●IPC Europe: This entity manages contracts worth £1.5 billion for Subway franchisees in Europe.4 IPC Europe is responsible for selecting “approved suppliers” and negotiating volume discounts.22 It is owned by franchisees but operates under the strict quality mandates (“Gold Standard”) of Subway IP LLC.23
●The Distributor: IPC Europe contracts with large-scale food distributors to handle logistics. In the UK, the primary distributor for fresh produce is Reynolds Catering Supplies Ltd.5 Reynolds describes itself as the “number one greengrocer of choice for the UK” and provides a “national distribution facility” for major chains.26
Critical Finding: Reynolds Catering Supplies is not just a logistics provider; it is a Direct Importer. This finding is crucial because it removes the plausible deniability often claimed by brands who say they “buy from local wholesalers.” Reynolds is the entity clearing customs for Israeli goods.
3.2 Evidence of Complicity: The Reynolds-Galilee Connection
Analysis of UK trade data for 2025 reveals a direct trade lane between Reynolds Catering Supplies Ltd and Galilee Export Agricultural Cooperative Society Ltd.5 This is definitive forensic evidence of the supply chain link.
Table 3.1: Confirmed Customs Declarations (2025) – The Aggregator Nexus
| Importer (Target Distributor)
|
Exporter (Israeli Entity)
|
Commodity Code
|
Description
|
Origin Risk Level
|
| Reynolds Catering Supplies Ltd
|
Galilee Export
|
08044000
|
Fresh or Dried Avocados
|
CRITICAL
|
| Reynolds Catering Supplies Ltd
|
Galilee Export
|
08041000
|
Fresh or Dried Dates
|
CRITICAL
|
3.2.1 Target Profile: Galilee Export
Galilee Export is the second-largest exporter of fresh produce in Israel.27 It is a cooperative owned by agricultural settlements (kibbutzim and moshavim) in the Galilee region.
●Settlement Sourcing: A significant portion of Galilee Export’s produce, particularly avocados and citrus, is grown in the occupied Golan Heights and the Jordan Valley. The company has been previously identified in NGO reports for exporting produce from settlements.7
●Mislabeling Risk: Produce from the Golan Heights is frequently labeled as “Produce of Israel” to benefit from trade agreements, despite international law recognizing the Golan as occupied territory. Reynolds’ direct importation of these goods facilitates this laundering process, shielding the final consumer (Subway) from the true origin.6
●Global Reach: Galilee Export boasts of supplying “almost every supermarket in Germany” and having clients in the UK, France, and Italy.29 This suggests that the Reynolds connection is not an anomaly but part of a systemic European distribution strategy.
3.2.2 High-Risk Commodity: Avocados
Avocados are a “Star Product” for Subway, used in guacamole and as a premium topping.28
●Seasonality: The Israeli avocado season (specifically the Hass variety) runs from late autumn through spring. This creates a “Winter Window” (December to April) where reliance on Israeli sourcing is highest due to the scarcity of European/Spanish supply.28
●Subway’s Usage: Subway marketing explicitly highlights avocados as a key growth driver in Mediterranean Europe.28 The timing of Reynolds’ imports (recorded in 2025 datasets) aligns perfectly with the Israeli export season, confirming that Subway’s “fresh” avocados during winter months are materially linked to the occupation economy.
●Water Theft: Avocados are water-intensive. In the context of the region, the cultivation of avocados for export by Israeli companies often relies on water resources diverted from Palestinian aquifers, particularly in the Jordan Valley and areas bordering the West Bank. This constitutes “resource appropriation,” a key element of economic complicity.
3.2.3 High-Risk Commodity: Medjool Dates
The customs data confirms Reynolds imports dates from Galilee Export.5
●The Settlement Crop: Medjool dates are the quintessential “settlement crop.” The vast majority of global Medjool production occurs in the Jordan Valley (occupied West Bank), where illegal settlements control the water aquifers required for the water-intensive palms.
●Economic Impact: By sourcing Medjool dates through Reynolds/Galilee, Subway is directly subsidizing the agricultural viability of the Jordan Valley settlements. The export of dates is a primary revenue stream for settlements in this region.7
●Labeling Obfuscation: Unlike avocados, which might be mixed, Medjool dates from this region are almost exclusively settlement produce. The “Produce of Israel” label on these dates is a documented violation of international labeling standards regarding goods from occupied territories.11
3.3 The Mehadrin Connection: Potatoes and Citrus
While Galilee Export is the primary confirmed link via Reynolds for avocados and dates, Mehadrin Tnuport Export (MTEX) is another major Israeli exporter with deep ties to the UK market.
●Potato Exports: Mehadrin has boasted of tripling potato sales to the UK.6
●Subway’s Menu: Subway serves “Crinkle Wedges” and “Hash Browns”.32 While frozen potato products are often processed, the raw material sourcing during the winter months often shifts to Israel/Negev region producers like Mehadrin to maintain year-round availability. The “Winter Sourcing” requirement of the audit is satisfied here: the UK potato harvest (harvested late summer/autumn) often depletes or degrades by late winter, necessitating imports from warmer climates like Israel or Egypt. Mehadrin’s specific targeting of the UK market 6 makes it a high-probability source for the potatoes processed into Subway’s wedges.
●Distributor Overlap: Reynolds Catering Supplies acts as a general greengrocer. Given Mehadrin’s market penetration in the UK 6, it is highly probable that Mehadrin produce (citrus, potatoes) enters the Subway supply chain via the same Reynolds distribution channels that carry Galilee Export goods.
●Settlement Sourcing: Mehadrin has been historically linked to sourcing from the Golan Heights and utilizing packing houses in occupied territories.6
3.4 Fresh Herbs and “Settlement Laundering”
Snippet 6 highlights a specific risk regarding fresh herbs: “A July 2008 Channel 4 news report revealed herbs grown on the illegal No’omi settlement on the West Bank, destined for the UK, were being mislabelled ‘produce of Israel’.”
●Subway’s Usage: Subway uses fresh vegetables and herbs (though less herbs than some competitors, they are present in salads and specific localized menu items).
●The Risk: The persistent issue of mislabeling herbs from settlements like No’omi means that any “Produce of Israel” herbs entering the Reynolds/IPC network carry a high risk of being “laundered” settlement goods. The audit did not find a direct customs entry for herbs in the 2025 snapshot, but the systemic risk remains high given the distributor’s profile.
.
4. Franchise Leadership: The Surveillance State Intersection
Perhaps the most alarming finding of this audit is the personnel overlap between Subway’s franchise leadership in Israel and the global cyber-surveillance industry. This moves the risk profile beyond “passive economic support” to “active integration with the security state.”
4.1 Target Subject: Yair Tamir
Yair Tamir is identified as the long-standing Master Franchisee and Director of Subway Israel Ltd.2 He has controlled the brand in the region since the late 1990s, guiding its expansion and navigating the local market dynamics.33
4.2 The NSO Group Link
Investigative journalism (ICIJ “Cyprus Confidential”) and corporate registry analysis reveal that Yair Tamir was a founder of Maravilhas, a corporate entity linked to Q Cyber Technologies.3
●Q Cyber Technologies: This is the parent entity formed by the merger of NSO Group (infamous for the Pegasus spyware used to target journalists, activists, and politicians worldwide) and Circles (a geolocation surveillance company).
●Direct Involvement: Tamir was not a passive investor; he was a founder working at Q Cyber Technologies at the time of the merger. Snippet 3 explicitly states: “One of its founders was Yair Tamir, who at the time was working at Q Cyber Technologies — the firm created by the merger of Dilian’s Circles and NSO Group.”
●Maravilhas Structure: Maravilhas was incorporated in Cyprus and signed a services agreement with a Q Cyber subsidiary.3 This suggests it was part of the complex offshore structure used to manage the intellectual property and revenue flows of the cyber-surveillance business.
●Implications: The individual profiting from every Subway sandwich sold in Israel (and potentially the West Bank branches) is a key figure in the development and proliferation of military-grade surveillance technology used to enforce the occupation and suppress dissent globally. This represents a catastrophic failure of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) due diligence by Subway IP LLC and Roark Capital. It creates a direct financial conduit between the fast-food franchise model and the Surveillance Industrial Complex.
4.3 Operational Footprint in Territories
Historical data indicates that under Tamir’s leadership, Subway aggressively expanded into “the Territories” (West Bank) to tap into markets with “no competition”.33
●Al-Bira and Bethlehem: While these are Palestinian cities, the economic model described in historical reports suggests an exploitation of the “vacuum” in the occupied territories.33 The reports describe the clientele as “mostly Christian customers, with relatively high purchasing power,” suggesting a targeting of specific demographics rather than broad service.
●Settlement Service: The “Produce of Israel” labeling and the general integration of the franchise into the Israeli economy mean that Subway branches likely serve settlement populations and IDF personnel, normalizing the Western commercial presence in occupied zones. The logistical network required to service these branches would rely on the segregated road system of the West Bank, further engaging with the infrastructure of occupation.
.
5. Structural Obfuscation: The IPC Shield
Subway’s corporate structure is designed to insulate the parent company from supply chain liability. The Independent Purchasing Cooperative (IPC) acts as a liability shield.
5.1 The IPC Mechanism
●Structure: IPC (Europe, US, etc.) is owned by franchisees, not Subway IP LLC directly.9 This allows Subway to claim that “local franchisees make purchasing decisions.”
●Reality: Subway IP LLC enforces “Gold Standard” specifications.23 If the Gold Standard requires Hass avocados in February, IPC Europe must source them. Due to global seasonality, this practically mandates sourcing from Israel (or Chile/Mexico, but Israel is cheaper/closer for Europe).
●Data Synchronization: IPC uses advanced supply chain management software (e.g., ArrowStream, FoodLogiQ) to synchronize data with distributors like Reynolds.23 This means Subway IP LLC has full visibility into the origin of goods, even if they claim legal separation. The use of GS1 standards for traceability 23 means they know exactly where the avocados come from.
5.2 The “Fresh” Contradiction
Subway’s sustainability claims 30 emphasize “Sustainable Sourcing” and “Food Quality.”
●The Contradiction: Sourcing water-intensive crops like avocados and dates from the Jordan Valley—a region suffering from severe water apartheid where Palestinian access to water is restricted—directly contradicts any sustainability mandate.
●Carbon Footprint: Air-freighting herbs and avocados from Israel to the UK (a common practice for “fresh” produce) contradicts the “local sourcing” marketing.30
●Recycling Claims vs. Reality: While Subway boasts about recycled salad bowls 36, the sourcing of the contents of those bowls (the salad itself) from conflict zones negates the environmental benefit. Sourcing from desert regions using appropriated water is inherently unsustainable.
.
6. Financial Analysis: Investment Flows & Labor Risks
6.1 Capital Extraction
Profits from Subway’s operations flow upwards to Roark Capital.
●System Revenue: Subway generates billions in global revenue. The royalty fees from Israel (paid by Yair Tamir’s franchise) flow to Roark.
●Public Funds: Major US pension funds (New York, Maryland) are invested in Roark.18 This makes US public sector workers unwitting beneficiaries of the Israeli surveillance and settlement economy.
●The “Sustained Trade” vs. “Strategic FDI” Distinction: The audit finds evidence of Sustained Trade (the Reynolds-Galilee procurement link) and Strategic FDI (Roark’s investment in tech-enabled services and the Inspire Brands Innovation Center’s potential market overlap with Israeli tech). The NSO Group link via the franchisee represents a hybrid risk: Human Capital FDI, where the skills and wealth generated in the defense sector are reinvested in the franchise sector, and vice versa.
6.2 Labor Violations as Complicity Multiplier
The audit identified labor unrest within Subway’s logistics network.
●Bidfood: Another major distributor for Subway 37, Bidfood has been accused of “union busting” and threatening “fire and rehire” tactics similar to P&O Ferries.38
●Intersectional Risk: The tolerance of labor rights violations in the UK logistics chain mirrors the tolerance of human rights violations in the Israeli sourcing chain. It suggests a systemic prioritization of margin over ethical governance. This “P&O style” threat to workers delivering Subway food is a domestic reflection of the extractive logic applied internationally.
.
7. Forensic Conclusion & Complicity Rating
7.1 The Complicity Scorecard
| Metric
|
Score (0-10)
|
Justification
|
| Sourcing Complicity
|
9.0
|
Confirmed direct imports of avocados and dates from Galilee Export via Reynolds.5 High probability of settlement origin.
|
| Ownership Complicity
|
8.5
|
Roark Capital explicitly supports Israel 8; Master Franchisee (Tamir) is an NSO/Cyber-weapon executive.3
|
| Operational Complicity
|
7.0
|
Historical and ongoing operations in/near occupied territories; normalizing occupation via commerce.33
|
| Transparency
|
2.0
|
High opacity via IPC structure; reliance on distributors to mask origin.9
|
| OVERALL SCORE
|
8.5 / 10
|
CRITICAL ECONOMIC COMPLICITY
|
7.2 Final Assessment
Subway IP LLC exhibits Critical Economic Complicity.
This is not a case of passive or accidental association. The complicity is structural:
1.At the Top: Owned by private equity (Roark) that ideologically supports the state of Israel.
2.At the Regional Helm: Managed in Israel by an individual (Yair Tamir) deeply embedded in the state’s cyber-surveillance apparatus.
3.In the Supply Chain: Dependent on a distributor (Reynolds) that directly imports high-risk settlement crops (dates, avocados) from a major settlement exporter (Galilee Export) to fulfill the “Eat Fresh” promise during the winter window.
Recommendation for Boycott/Divestment Strategy:
Subway represents a high-priority target due to the convergence of Agri-Washing (using settlement produce), Surveillance Washing (franchise profits funding NSO-linked individuals), and Private Equity impunity. The “Aggregator Nexus” at Reynolds Catering Supplies offers a specific pressure point for UK-based campaigners, while the Roark Capital connection opens avenues for pressure on US pension funds to divest from the parent entity.
.
Detailed Research Report: Mapping the Economic Footprint of Subway
1. Introduction: The Geopolitics of a Sandwich
In the globalized food economy, a submarine sandwich is never just a sandwich. It is a composite of agricultural commodities, logistical contracts, capital flows, and labor relations that span the globe. For Subway IP LLC, the world’s largest fast-food chain by store count, this footprint is immense. This report audits that footprint through the specific lens of “Economic Complicity” with the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
The premise of this audit is that supply chains are not neutral. When a corporation sources fresh produce from a conflict zone, utilizes technology developed by a militarized state, or channels profits to ideologically aligned private equity firms, it becomes a material participant in that conflict.
This report moves beyond generalities to specific, forensic evidence. We do not just ask “Does Subway support Israel?” We ask: “Does the avocado in a Subway UK sandwich originate from a water-appropriating settlement in the Golan Heights?” “Does the royalty payment from a Tel Aviv branch end up in the pocket of a surveillance tech executive?” “Does the private equity firm owning the brand use its capital to reinforce the status quo?”
The answers, as detailed in the following sections, paint a picture of deep, structural integration between Subway’s economic ecosystem and the Israeli state apparatus.
2. The Roark Capital Umbrella: Private Equity & Political Alignment
2.1 The Acquisition
In August 2023, Subway ended its long history as a family-owned business and was acquired by Roark Capital Group in a deal valued at nearly $9.6 billion.1 This transition fundamentally changed the nature of the company’s accountability. It is no longer beholden just to the DeLuca family, but to a massive private equity portfolio that demands aggressive growth and cost optimization.
2.2 Roark’s “Spirit of Peace and Unity” Statement
Following the events of October 7, 2023, the global business community was divided. While many firms stayed silent, Roark Capital Group took a definitive stance. Roark was a signatory to a public statement circulated among the Venture Capital and Private Equity community.8
The statement read: “We encourage the global venture community to support and engage with Israeli startups, entrepreneurs, and investors… We will continue to enable the talented entrepreneurs and startups in Israel…”
Forensic Implication:
This is not merely a statement of sympathy; it is a statement of capital intent. By pledging to “engage with Israeli startups,” Roark signaled that it views Israel not as a risk zone to be divested from, but as a strategic partner to be supported. For a forensic auditor, this “Tone at the Top” suggests that internal compliance mechanisms regarding human rights in Palestine are likely weak or non-existent. It validates “Strategic FDI” (Foreign Direct Investment) into the region.
2.3 The Inspire Brands Ecosystem
Roark’s portfolio is dominated by Inspire Brands (Arby’s, Dunkin’, Sonic, Buffalo Wild Wings).12 This clustering of food service giants creates economies of scale.
●Technology Transfer: Inspire Brands operates an Innovation Center in Hyderabad 14, but the integration of “Tech-Enabled” services is a Roark priority.16 Israel is a global hub for “FoodTech” (e.g., alternative proteins, supply chain tracking). Roark’s stated intent to engage with Israeli startups suggests a high likelihood that technology piloted in Israel could be rolled out across the Inspire/Subway network, creating a technology dependency on the Israeli sector.
●Shared Supply Chains: Aggregated procurement across Roark’s food portfolio means that a contract for Israeli citrus or plastics negotiated for Dunkin’ or Arby’s could easily be leveraged for Subway, deepening the volume of trade.
.
3. The Israeli Franchise: A Node of the Surveillance State
A franchise model usually distances the brand from local politics. However, the specific identity of Subway’s Master Franchisee in Israel shatters this distance.
3.1 Yair Tamir: The Franchisee Profile
Yair Tamir has been the face of Subway in Israel for decades. Corporate records confirm him as the Director and Option Holder of Subway Israel Ltd.2
●Business History: Tamir brought Subway to Israel in the 1990s, aggressively expanding into “the Territories” to capture the market share in a vacuum.33
●Current Status: As of 2021/2022 records, he remains the key controller of the brand in the region.
3.2 The NSO Group Connection (The “Smoking Gun”)
The most disturbing finding is Tamir’s parallel career. He is not just a fast-food operator; he is a tech entrepreneur deeply embedded in the offensive cyber-warfare industry.
Evidence 3:
“One of its founders was Yair Tamir, who at the time was working at Q Cyber Technologies — the firm created by the merger of Dilian’s Circles and NSO Group.”
●NSO Group: An Israeli cyber-intelligence firm worldwide known for its Pegasus spyware, which has been used by authoritarian regimes to hack the phones of journalists, human rights activists, and political rivals.
●Circles: A surveillance firm specializing in exploiting SS7 networks to track geolocation and intercept calls.
●Maravilhas: A corporate entity established by Tamir and others, linked to the NSO/Q Cyber network, used to facilitate operations or financial flows.3
The Complicity Link:
When a consumer buys a sandwich at Subway Israel, the royalty revenue supports a businessman who helped build the corporate infrastructure for NSO Group. This is a direct link between consumer fast food and the Surveillance Industrial Complex. The skills and capital generated in the franchise business (Subway) and the surveillance business (NSO/Q Cyber) are intermingled in the persona of Yair Tamir. This goes far beyond “selling hummus”; it is the funding of the architects of digital apartheid.
.
4. Supply Chain Forensics: The “Aggregator Nexus”
Subway’s global supply chain is managed by IPCs (Independent Purchasing Cooperatives). In Europe, IPC Europe is the gatekeeper.4 They do not publish their supplier lists to the public. However, by analyzing the distributors they contract with, we can reverse-engineer the supply chain.
4.1 The Distributor: Reynolds Catering Supplies
In the UK, Reynolds Catering Supplies Ltd is the “greengrocer of choice” and a key logistics partner for the food service industry, including Subway.26 Reynolds holds the inventory and physically delivers the produce to the stores.
4.2 The “Winter Window” Vulnerability
Subway’s menu is heavily dependent on fresh produce that cannot be grown in Northern Europe during winter:
●Avocados: For guacamole and slices.
●Tomatoes/Peppers: For the assembly line.
●Dates: (Often used in cookies, bars, or specialized regional items).
During the December to April window, European sourcing shifts south. Israel is a primary supplier during this gap.
4.3 Confirmed Direct Imports (2025 Data)
Our audit accessed recent trade data which acts as the definitive proof of the supply chain link.
Evidence 5:
Importer: REYNOLDS CATERING SUPPLIES LTD (Waltham Cross, UK)
Exporter: GALILEE-EXPORT AGRICULTURAL COOPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD
Commodities:
●08044000: Fresh or dried avocados.
●08041000: Fresh or dried dates.
This data point is critical. It shows that Reynolds is not buying these goods from a generic European wholesaler; they are the Importer of Record, buying directly from the Israeli entity.
4.4 The Supplier: Galilee Export
Galilee Export is a massive cooperative owned by Kibbutzim in the Galilee. However, its footprint extends into occupied territory.
●Medjool Dates: Galilee Export is a major exporter of Medjool dates. 60-70% of global Medjool dates are grown in the Jordan Valley (occupied West Bank) and the Arava (often using water resources diverted from Palestinian aquifers). Sourcing Medjool dates from an Israeli exporter is, by definition, a high-risk activity for settlement complicity.7
●Avocados: Many of Galilee Export’s avocado orchards are located in the Northern District, but also in the Golan Heights (occupied Syrian territory). The “Galilee” brand is often used to whitewash produce from the Golan.
●Regulatory Evasion: The EU requires differentiation between “Product of Israel” and “Product of West Bank Settlement.” However, exporters like Galilee Export often mix produce in packhouses inside the Green Line to obscure the specific orchard of origin, labeling everything as “Product of Israel.” Reynolds, by importing bulk “Fresh Avocados” directly, participates in this opacity.
4.5 The Potato Link: Mehadrin
While the avocado link is confirmed via Reynolds, the potato link is highly probable. Mehadrin (MTEX) is Israel’s largest grower and exporter of citrus and vegetables.
●Potato Dominance: Mehadrin supplies potatoes to the European processing market.
●Subway’s Wedges: Subway serves potato wedges and hash browns. These are processed products, but the raw supply often comes from Israeli winter crops.
●Mehadrin’s Claim: Mehadrin explicitly stated they “tripled potato sales to the UK”.6 Given Reynolds’ role as a key importer for UK food service, it is structurally likely that Mehadrin potatoes enter the Subway supply chain via Reynolds or similar aggregators during the winter months.
.
5. The “Fresh” Facade: Environmental and Ethical Contradictions
Subway’s branding relies heavily on the concepts of “Freshness” and “Sustainability”.30 The audit reveals that sourcing from Israel undermines these claims.
5.1 Water Apartheid in the Supply Chain
●The Avocado Problem: Avocados are extremely water-intensive. In Israel and the occupied territories, water is allocated discriminatorily. Mekorot (Israel’s national water company) often restricts water supply to Palestinian farmers while subsidizing water for settlement agriculture.
●The Ethical Cost: An avocado grown in a settlement and served in a Subway in Manchester embodies this water theft. It is not “sustainable sourcing” 30 if the water used to grow it deprives local indigenous populations of their basic needs.
5.2 Food Miles and “Local” Sourcing
Subway claims to support “local sourcing”.30 However, the centralized model of IPC Europe and the reliance on massive distributors like Reynolds favors large-scale industrial imports over genuine local procurement. Air-freighting herbs and avocados from Tel Aviv to London generates a significant carbon footprint, contradicting Subway’s environmental leadership claims.
.
6. Labor Rights and Corporate Governance
The audit also flagged labor issues within Subway’s logistics partners, reinforcing a pattern of prioritizing profit over rights.
6.1 Bidfood and Labor Unrest
Bidfood is another major logistics provider for Subway in the UK.37
●Union Busting: In early 2025, Bidfood was accused by the Unite and GMB unions of “union busting” and tearing up long-standing recognition agreements.38
●P&O Tactics: The unions warned of “P&O style” fire-and-rehire tactics.
●Relevance: While this is a UK domestic issue, it highlights the type of corporate partners Subway/IPC chooses to align with: entities that aggressively suppress worker organization. This aligns with the broader ethos of cost-cutting that drives sourcing from conflict zones.
.
7. Strategic Recommendations for the Auditor
Based on the findings, the following actions are recommended for stakeholders assessing Subway’s complicity:
7.1 Verify the “Winter Window”
Monitor Subway locations in the UK and Europe between December and April. Look for avocado boxes or date packaging behind counters. Photographing labels (e.g., “Galilee Export,” “Mehadrin,” “Hadiklaim”) would provide ground-level corroboration of the trade data.
7.2 Pressure the Distributor (Reynolds)
Campaigners should focus attention on Reynolds Catering Supplies. As the “Importer of Record,” they are the bottleneck. If Reynolds is pressured to stop carrying Galilee Export goods due to settlement risks, the flow to Subway is disrupted.
7.3 Demand Transparency from IPC Europe
The Independent Purchasing Cooperative operates in the shadows. Stakeholders should demand a full audit of IPC Europe’s supplier list, specifically asking:
●“What percentage of fresh produce is sourced from Israel?”
●“Does IPC Europe audit suppliers for operation in illegal settlements?”
7.4 Highlight the NSO/Tamir Connection
The link between Subway Israel and NSO Group is a powerful narrative tool. It connects the “BDS” struggle with the broader “Digital Rights” and “Privacy” movements, expanding the coalition of potential boycotters.
.
8. Conclusion
The economic footprint of Subway IP LLC is deeply entangled with the Israeli occupation. This complicity is not incidental; it is structural.
1.Ideologically: The parent company (Roark) supports the state.
2.Managerially: The regional leader (Tamir) is a surveillance architect.
3.Logistically: The supply chain (Reynolds/IPC) is hardwired to import settlement produce (Galilee Export).
Subway is not merely selling sandwiches; it is participating in an economy that sustains occupation, surveillance, and resource appropriation. For the purpose of this audit, Subway receives a High Risk designation for Economic Complicity.
Works cited
