Costco

1. Executive Dossier Summary

Company: Costco Wholesale Corporation

Jurisdiction: United States (Headquarters: Issaquah, Washington)

Sector: Consumer Discretionary / Mass Merchant Retail / Global Logistics

Leadership: Hamilton E. James (Chairman), Ron Vachris (CEO)

Intelligence Conclusions:

High Structural Complicity via “Gray Zone” Logistics:

The forensic audit establishes that Costco Wholesale Corporation functions as a systemic “Gray Zone” logistical node for the Israeli economy. While the corporation has publicly declined recent overtures from the Israeli Ministry of Finance to establish physical “brick-and-mortar” retail operations within the state—citing market size rather than political objection—it maintains deep, structural economic ties through mechanisms of “Sustained Trade” and “Private Label Integration.” The audit reveals that Costco’s proprietary Kirkland Signature supply chain acts as a direct capitalization channel for Israeli industrial firms. This is most visible in the high-volume manufacturing contracts for generic pharmaceuticals (sourced from Perrigo in the Negev development town of Yeruham) and hygiene products (sourced from Albaad in Massuot Yitzhak). This relationship transcends passive wholesale purchasing; it constitutes a quasi-operational partnership where Costco’s global volume sustains the viability of specific Israeli export sectors, effectively subsidizing the state’s industrial base without the visibility of a physical storefront.¹

Digital Sovereignty Compromise & The “Unit 8200” Stack:

A deep technographic audit reveals a state of High Digital Complicity that is arguably more profound than its physical trade ties. Costco’s enterprise security architecture has been effectively captured by the Israeli cybersecurity ecosystem. The corporation relies on a “Full-Spectrum” defensive stack comprising Check Point (Network Security), Wiz (Cloud Security), SentinelOne (Endpoint Detection), and CyberArk (Identity Management). This dependency creates a “Digital Iron Dome” over Costco’s operations, placing the integrity, visibility, and access control of its $250 billion annual revenue stream in the hands of vendors with deep, verified ties to the Israeli military-intelligence complex (specifically IDF Unit 8200). Furthermore, the integration of Hello Heart into the employee benefits ecosystem via its subsidiary Navitus Health Solutions opens a critical vector for the transfer of U.S. workforce biometric data to Israeli R&D centers, raising significant data sovereignty and privacy concerns.³

Political Hypocrisy & The “Safe Harbor” Double Standard:

The audit identifies a glaring geopolitical double standard in Costco’s corporate governance, characterized as the “Safe Harbor” doctrine. The corporation swiftly suspended operations and purchasing in Russia following the February 2022 invasion of Ukraine, citing moral and operational imperatives aligned with Western sanctions. Conversely, despite the International Court of Justice (ICJ) plausibility ruling on genocide in Gaza and documented evidence of its supply chain provisioning the IDF (via gray market channels), Costco has maintained a “Business as Usual” stance regarding Israel. This divergence confirms that the company’s “ethical sourcing” is politically selective, activating only when aligned with U.S. State Department directives. The presence of Chairman Hamilton E. James on the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board structurally aligns Costco’s governance with the U.S. national security establishment, effectively insulating the company from pressure to divest from strategic U.S. allies.⁵

Material Support for the Settlement Enterprise:

Costco acts as a critical high-volume distribution node for goods manufactured or grown in illegal Israeli settlements, in direct violation of international law. The continued procurement and retail of Keter Plastic products (linked to the Barkan Industrial Zone) and Hadiklaim dates (grown in Jordan Valley settlements) constitute direct economic engagement with entities operating in occupied territory. The audit confirms a high risk of “Settlement Laundering,” where produce from the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT) is integrated into Costco’s supply chain under generic “Product of Israel” labels, confusing consumers and bypassing ethical screening mechanisms.²

2. Corporate Overview & Evolution

Origins & Founders

Costco was founded in 1983 in Seattle, Washington, by James (Jim) Sinegal and Jeffrey Brotman. The partnership merged Sinegal’s operational expertise, honed under Sol Price at Price Club, with Brotman’s capital formation skills and legal background.

• Jeffrey Brotman: Born to Jewish immigrants from Romania, Brotman was a pivotal figure in the Pacific Northwest Jewish community. He was a major donor to the Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle and various Zionist causes, and his philanthropic legacy remains deeply entwined with Jewish communal structures.⁸ While his motivations were likely personal and philanthropic, they established a corporate DNA that viewed Israel as a cultural and economic partner rather than a foreign market.
• Jim Sinegal: While less publicly political, Sinegal’s operational discipline created the efficiency model that now relies on global sourcing, including the integration of Israeli technological and agricultural innovations.¹⁰

Assessment: The founders’ legacy has evolved from personal affinity to structural alignment. What began as individual philanthropy has calcified into a corporate strategy that treats Israel as a “Silicon Wadi” partner and a reliable agricultural source, insulating it from the ethical scrutiny applied to other conflict zones.

Leadership & Ownership

The current governance structure reflects a fusion of high finance, retail operations, and the U.S. national security state, creating a formidable barrier to BDS compliance.

• Hamilton E. James (Chairman of the Board):
  • Background: Former President and Chief Operating Officer of The Blackstone Group, one of the world’s largest private equity firms.
  • Political Ties: James is a major fundraiser for the Democratic Party establishment and sits on the board of the Center for American Progress, a think tank that traditionally supports the U.S.-Israel alliance.¹²
  • State Integration: Most critically, James was appointed by President Biden to the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board (PIAB) in March 2023.⁶ This position grants him high-level security clearance and places him in an advisory role regarding the effectiveness of the U.S. intelligence community.
  • Assessment: James’s dual role in global capital (Blackstone) and U.S. intelligence (PIAB) creates a governance framework of “Capitalist Neutrality” that is subordinate to U.S. foreign policy interests. His leadership ensures Costco remains a “Safe Harbor” for U.S.-aligned geopolitical interests. It is structurally improbable for a Chairman advising the President on intelligence to authorize a boycott of Israel, a key U.S. intelligence partner. His receipt of a direct solicitation from Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich highlights his perceived status as a geopolitical asset.¹⁴
• Gina Raimondo (Board Director Nominee):
  • Background: Former U.S. Secretary of Commerce (2021-2025) and Governor of Rhode Island.
  • Record: As Commerce Secretary, Raimondo oversaw the U.S. export control regime. During the 2023-2024 assault on Gaza, she faced intense pressure from human rights groups to suspend firearm exports to Israel but refused to leverage her department’s authority to do so.¹⁶
  • Assessment: Her nomination to Costco’s board brings the architect of the U.S. refusal to sanction Israel directly into the company’s governance. This solidifies Costco’s alignment with the state’s position: that trade with Israel must be protected regardless of human rights violations. Her presence signals a reinforcement of the “Safe Harbor” strategy against activist shareholder proposals.¹⁸
• Ron Vachris (CEO):
  • Profile: A career Costco operator who rose from a forklift driver position.
  • Stance: Vachris adheres to a “Strategy of Silence,” focusing purely on operational efficiency and member value while studiously avoiding political discourse.
  • Assessment: In the context of corporate complicity, silence is consent. Vachris’s refusal to engage with the ethical implications of the supply chain allows the “gray zone” logistics to continue unimpeded. His focus on “digital transformation” has accelerated the adoption of the Israeli cyber-stack, prioritizing “best-of-breed” security over data sovereignty concerns.⁵

Analytical Assessment

Costco’s corporate structure functions as a Geopolitical Stabilizer for the U.S.-Israel alliance. It provides a massive, reliable commercial interface for Israeli goods and technology, insulating the Israeli economy from the effects of isolation. The leadership’s deep integration with the U.S. political and intelligence establishment (via James and Raimondo) creates a “Governance Firewall” that prevents the adoption of BDS principles. The company views Israel not as a conflict zone subject to human rights due diligence (like Russia), but as a “Western” market and a critical technology partner. This “Gray Zone” logistical support—manufacturing in Israel without opening stores there—allows Costco to extract economic value and provide industrial support while maintaining a veneer of distance that creates “plausible deniability” regarding direct occupation involvement.

3. Timeline of Relevant Events

Date	Event	Significance
March 2005	Perrigo Acquires Agis Industries	Perrigo Company completes the acquisition of Agis Industries (1983) Ltd., Israel’s second-largest pharmaceutical company. This strategic move establishes the manufacturing base in Yeruham that would later produce Kirkland Signature generics, structurally integrating Costco’s private label supply chain with the Israeli industrial base in the Negev.21
2009-2010	Ahava Boycott Campaigns	Global protests target retailers selling Ahava products due to their manufacture in the illegal West Bank settlement of Mitzpe Shalem. Costco faces pressure but maintains a mixed stance, occasionally stocking the brand while facing localized protests.23
2016	Instacart Partnership Begins	Costco partners with Instacart for same-day delivery. This digital expansion eventually necessitates robust cybersecurity, paving the way for the adoption of the Israeli security stack to protect member data and transactions.25
Aug 2017	Hamilton James Elected Chairman	Following the death of co-founder Jeffrey Brotman, Hamilton E. James is elected Chairman of the Board. This marks the shift from founder-led philanthropy to technocratic, finance-led governance aligned with U.S. strategic interests.6
March 2020	Acquisition of Navitus Health Interest	Costco purchases a minority equity interest in Navitus Health Solutions. This acquisition is the precursor to the integration of the Israeli digital health firm Hello Heart into Costco’s employee benefits ecosystem, creating a vector for biometric data transfer.26
Feb 2022	Suspension of Russia Operations	Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Costco suspends operations and purchasing in Russia. This establishes the “Safe Harbor” Precedent: the corporation demonstrates it can and will exit a market for moral/political reasons when aligned with U.S. foreign policy.28
Feb 2023	Smotrich Solicitation Letter	Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich writes a formal letter to Chairman Hamilton James and CEO Craig Jelinek, inviting Costco to enter the Israeli market to “break the monopoly” and lower the cost of living. This identifies Costco as a strategic target for Israeli economic statecraft.15
March 2023	James Appointed to PIAB	President Biden appoints Hamilton James to the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board. This deepens the structural link between Costco’s governance and the U.S. national security apparatus, reinforcing the “Safe Harbor” alignment.6
Oct 2023	Gaza Genocide & “Business as Usual”	Following the October 7 attacks and subsequent bombardment of Gaza, Costco refuses to apply the “Russia Standard” to Israel. Supply chains for Keter, Hadiklaim, and Perrigo remain active, and Kirkland products appear on IDF logistical lists.5
2024	Membership Scanner Rollout	Costco begins deploying tablet-based membership scanners at warehouse entrances. While ostensibly for verification, the hardware is surveillance-ready, aligning with the “Retail Panopticon” trend dominated by Israeli computer vision firms.3
Sept 2025	Hello Heart Partnership Launch	Navitus Health Solutions officially partners with Hello Heart (Israel) to provide digital cardiac health tracking to members. This operationalizes the transfer of U.S. employee biometric data to Israeli R&D centers.4
Dec 2025	Gina Raimondo Nominated to Board	Former Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo is nominated to the Costco Board of Directors. Her tenure was marked by a refusal to restrict firearm exports to Israel, signaling a continued commitment to unrestricted trade flows.18

4. Domains of Complicity

Domain 1: Military & Intelligence Complicity (V-MIL)

Goal: To establish whether Costco provides material support, dual-use technology, or logistical sustainment to the Israeli military apparatus (IDF), the Ministry of Defense (IMOD), or the broader defense industrial base.

Evidence & Analysis:

1. Direct Capital Injection via Pharmaceutical Manufacturing (The Perrigo Nexus)

The audit identifies a critical “High Impact” vector of complicity in the manufacturing of Costco’s proprietary brand, Kirkland Signature. Forensic examination of FDA drug labels confirms that high-volume generic pharmaceuticals are manufactured by Perrigo Israel Pharmaceuticals (a subsidiary of Perrigo Company plc).

• The Products: Specifically, Kirkland Signature Minoxidil Topical Solution USP, 5% (Hair Regrowth Treatment for Men) and Kirkland Signature Diclofenac Sodium Topical Gel, 1% (NSAID) bear the explicit marking: “Made in Israel“.¹⁴
• The Location: The manufacturing facility is located in Yeruham, a strategic development town in the Negev desert. Yeruham was established to populate the peripheral Negev region, often at the expense of Bedouin land rights, and is a key node in the Zionist project of “blooming the desert” through industrialization.
• Systemic Implication: This is not a passive retail relationship; it is a Direct Manufacturing Contract. Costco dictates the specifications, volume, branding, and price points to the Israeli manufacturer. By sourcing its private label generics from Yeruham, Costco provides essential capital, employment stability, and tax revenue to a peripheral Israeli town. The volume required to supply Costco’s global network implies a massive, continuous production line running in Israel solely to service this contract. This creates a “sticky” supply chain dependency that is difficult to sever, structurally integrating Costco into the Israeli industrial base.

2. Proliferation of Dual-Use Tactical Systems (The DJI Drone Vector)

Costco acts as a primary, unregulated point of sale for DJI drone platforms, specifically the Mini and Mavic series. While these are ostensibly consumer goods, intelligence confirms that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) systematically retrofits these specific COTS (Commercial Off-The-Shelf) units for tactical operations in Gaza.14

• Mechanism of Use: Reports indicate these drones are used for “suicide” missions (retrofitted with explosives), tactical surveillance of tunnels, and the “mosquito” protocol where Palestinian prisoners are forced to carry drones into dangerous areas.
• Complicity: Unlike defense contractors who must perform End-User Monitoring (EUM) and adhere to strict export controls, Costco’s bulk-sales model allows for the rapid, untraceable procurement of these assets. A procurement agent for the IDF or a donor organization can purchase “Aerial Bundles” at Costco Business Centers without triggering any “Know Your Customer” (KYC) alarms. Costco effectively functions as the unwitting (or willfully blind) arsenal for the IDF’s asymmetric drone warfare capability, providing a steady stream of disposable air assets that bypass formal military procurement channels.

3. Logistical Permeation of the IDF Supply Chain

Intelligence reveals that “Kirkland Signature” products appear on IDF Kosher-for-Passover logistical lists.14 This confirms that Costco’s private label goods are physically present in IDF mess halls and bases.

• The “Gray Market” Logistics: Since Costco has no physical stores in Israel, this permeation occurs through a robust network of parallel importers and freight forwarders. These entities utilize Costco’s “Export Consolidation” services ¹⁴ to purchase bulk goods in the U.S. (often New Jersey or New York) and ship them to Israel.
• Significance: Costco’s refusal to open a store in Israel does not prevent it from feeding the Israeli army. By facilitating bulk export consolidation without end-user restrictions, Costco integrates itself into the IDF’s institutional catering supply chain via intermediaries. The “Kirkland” brand thus becomes a component of the logistical sustainment of the military occupation.

Counter-Arguments & Assessment:

• Counter-Argument: Costco sells DJI drones globally to all consumers; IDF usage is third-party misuse beyond Costco’s control.
• Rebuttal: While true for individual sales, the bulk procurement patterns associated with conflict zones create a due diligence obligation. Given the widely reported weaponization of these specific models in Gaza, continuing unrestricted bulk sales to freight forwarders servicing the region constitutes negligence.
• Counter-Argument: Perrigo is a global company; sourcing from Israel is a cost decision, not a political one.
• Rebuttal: Perrigo’s Israeli operations are a specific legacy of the Agis acquisition. Costco has the option to source generics from India or Europe (as it does for other items). The decision to maintain the Yeruham contract reflects a prioritization of the Israeli trade relationship and a refusal to treat the Negev industrial zone as politically sensitive.

Analytical Assessment: Moderate-High Confidence. Costco is not a defense contractor in the traditional sense, but its role as a “Logistical Enabler” is significant. The direct manufacturing of Kirkland goods in Israel and the proliferation of dual-use drones create a material link to the occupation’s sustainability.

Named Entities / Evidence Map:

• Perrigo Israel Pharmaceuticals (Yeruham) -> Manufacturer of Kirkland Signature Minoxidil/Diclofenac.¹⁴
• DJI (Consumer Drones) -> Sold in bulk by Costco, retrofitted by IDF for kinetic use.¹⁴
• IDF Logistics -> Lists Kirkland products for institutional use.¹⁴

Domain 2: Digital & Technographic Complicity (V-DIG)

Goal: To conduct a technographic audit of Costco’s digital infrastructure to determine reliance on Israeli technology vendors (specifically those linked to Unit 8200) and assess data sovereignty risks regarding employee and customer data.

Evidence & Analysis:

1. The “Unit 8200” Cyber-Kinetic Stack

Costco has achieved a status of High Structural Complicity through its enterprise cybersecurity architecture. The audit reveals a “Full-Spectrum” reliance on Israeli vendors for every critical layer of defense, creating a “Digital Iron Dome” over the corporation.3

• Identity (CyberArk): Costco utilizes CyberArk (HQ: Petach Tikva) to secure privileged administrative credentials. This grants an Israeli-engineered system oversight over the “keys to the kingdom”—monitoring who accesses what at the highest levels of the corporate hierarchy. Recent integrations with SentinelOne allow for automated revocation of access based on behavioral analysis.³
• Cloud (Wiz): As Costco migrates legacy AS400 systems to Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud Platform (GCP), it secures these environments with Wiz (founded by Unit 8200 alumni). Wiz operates via an “agentless” approach, creating a “Security Graph” of the entire cloud estate. This means the map and blueprint of Costco’s digital infrastructure are generated, visualized, and analyzed by Israeli algorithms.³
• Endpoint (SentinelOne): Costco deploys SentinelOne (HQ: Tel Aviv) on corporate devices and Point-of-Sale (POS) systems. This software operates at the kernel level—the deepest layer of the operating system—granting an Israeli firm absolute visibility and control over Costco’s endpoints. The “autonomous response” capability means Costco’s digital self-defense is automated by Israeli rules of engagement, capable of killing processes or isolating devices without human intervention.³
• Network (Check Point): The legacy perimeter is secured by Check Point, the foundational company of the Israeli cyber sector.³

2. The Biometric Data Vector: Hello Heart

Through its subsidiary Navitus Health Solutions, Costco has operationalized a partnership with Hello Heart, an Israeli digital therapeutics firm.3

• Mechanism: In September 2025, Navitus launched this partnership, offering a Bluetooth-enabled blood pressure monitor to members. The device feeds biometric data (blood pressure, pulse, activity levels) into an app powered by AI algorithms (“Nia”) developed and maintained in Tel Aviv.
• Sovereignty Risk: This represents a direct vector for the transfer of sensitive biological data from the U.S. workforce (Costco employees) to Israeli analytical engines. Unlike financial data, biometric data is immutable. The processing of this data by foreign R&D centers raises profound privacy and national security concerns regarding the “biological mapping” of the American workforce.

3. Surveillance Readiness and the “Retail Panopticon”

In 2024, Costco rolled out tablet-based membership scanners at warehouse entrances.31 While currently stated to be for membership verification, the hardware is surveillance-ready.

• The Slippery Slope: The move toward “frictionless” retail (to compete with Sam’s Club) pushes Costco toward computer vision technologies. This sector is monopolized by Israeli firms like Trigo, Trax, and Corsight. The deployment of these scanners creates the physical infrastructure for a future switch to facial recognition, aligning Costco with the “surveillance state” model perfected in the occupied territories.³

Counter-Arguments & Assessment:

• Counter-Argument: These are “Best of Breed” global security tools; their origin is irrelevant to their function.
• Rebuttal: In cybersecurity, origin is function. The intimate ties between Israeli tech firms and the IDF (Unit 8200) mean that these tools are often dual-use technologies derived from military signals intelligence. Relying on them creates a strategic dependency on a foreign military-industrial complex. If a geopolitical rift were to occur, Costco’s digital infrastructure would be vulnerable to the state that holds the keys.

Analytical Assessment: High Confidence. The dependency is structural, critical, and pervasive. Costco cannot operate its cloud, endpoints, or identity systems without Israeli technology. The Hello Heart partnership escalates this from “passive use” to “active biometric data transfer.”

Named Entities / Evidence Map:

• Check Point / Wiz / SentinelOne / CyberArk -> The “Unit 8200 Stack” securing Costco.³
• Hello Heart (Tel Aviv R&D) -> Biometric data collection via Navitus.⁴
• Navitus Health Solutions -> Costco subsidiary facilitating the Israeli partnership.²⁶

Domain 3: Economic & Structural Complicity (V-ECON)

Goal: To map the economic flows between Costco and the Israeli economy, focusing on the “Aggregator Nexus,” settlement goods, private label manufacturing, and the risks of “Settlement Laundering.”

Evidence & Analysis:

1. The Aggregator Nexus and Settlement Laundering

Costco’s fresh produce supply chain is heavily reliant on a small oligopoly of Israeli agricultural exporters: Hadiklaim, Mehadrin (MTEX), Galilee Export, and Arava Export Growers.2

• The Mechanism: These aggregators function as vertically integrated conglomerates that operate extensive packing houses and cultivation areas in illegal Jordan Valley settlements (e.g., Tomer, Beqa’ot, Mehola). They systematically co-mingle settlement produce with produce grown inside the Green Line.
• Forensic Finding: Costco serves as a primary distribution channel for Hadiklaim dates (sold under “Jordan River” or “Kirkland Signature”) and Mehadrin citrus (sold under “Jaffa”). The audit confirms that “Kirkland Signature Organic Medjool Dates” list “Israel” as the origin, indicating a Direct Private Label Contract with Hadiklaim. Given that Hadiklaim sources up to 60% of its dates from the Jordan Valley, it is statistically certain that Costco is selling dates grown on stolen Palestinian land under its own brand name.² This “white-labeling” effectively launders the settlement origin, presenting it to consumers as a generic Costco product.

2. The Settlement Industrial Complex: Keter Plastic

Costco is a major retailer of Keter Plastic products (sheds, resin furniture, planters).2

• The Link: Keter operates major manufacturing facilities in the Barkan Industrial Zone, an illegal settlement in the West Bank. Barkan is built on land confiscated from the Palestinian villages of Haris, Bruqin, and Sarta.
• Complicity: By providing high-volume, prime floor space to Keter products, Costco provides the economies of scale necessary to sustain these settlement factories. The revenue generated flows back to Keter, which pays taxes to the Shomron Regional Council (a settler governance body), directly funding the infrastructure of the occupation. Recent collaborations with Tetra Pak to produce “sustainable planters” represent a form of “Greenwashing,” masking the occupation-based origin of the manufacturing with an environmental narrative.³⁸

3. Private Label Integration: Albaad Massuot

Costco sources its Kirkland Signature moist flushable wipes and baby wipes from Albaad Massuot Yitzhak Ltd..2

• Implication: Albaad is a publicly traded Israeli company based in a kibbutz (Massuot Yitzhak). This contract represents a massive, recurring revenue stream that bolsters Israeli industrial output. Unlike spot-market purchasing, this is a long-term strategic partnership where Costco is deeply integrated into the manufacturer’s production planning. This creates a relationship of mutual economic dependence.

4. The “Winter Window” Seasonality

Costco utilizes a “Winter Window” sourcing strategy (December to April) where it relies heavily on Israeli imports for citrus, peppers, and avocados to fill the gap in North American production.2

• Significance: During these months, Costco effectively functions as the export arm for Israeli agriculture. The predictability of this seasonal demand allows Israeli aggregators to plan cultivation and expansion, including in settlement areas.

Counter-Arguments & Assessment:

• Counter-Argument: Costco relies on “origin switching” and sources dates/citrus from other countries (e.g., US, Peru) during different seasons.
• Rebuttal: The existence of alternative sources for part of the year does not negate the material support provided during the Israeli season. The “Complicity Gap” exists specifically during the Winter Window when Costco becomes a primary lifelines for Israeli agricultural exports.
• Counter-Argument: Keter has factories inside the Green Line as well.
• Rebuttal: Money is fungible. Profits from Costco sales support the corporate entity that maintains and invests in the Barkan facility. Furthermore, the lack of transparency prevents consumers from knowing which specific shed came from Barkan versus Carmiel.

Analytical Assessment: High Confidence. The economic ties are “High Proximity” due to the private label contracts. Costco is not just buying Israeli goods; it is branding them as its own (Kirkland), staking its reputation on the output of the settlement economy.

Named Entities / Evidence Map:

• Hadiklaim (Dates) -> Jordan Valley Settlements (Tomer) -> Kirkland Signature Dates.²
• Mehadrin (Citrus) -> Jaffa Brand -> Costco Winter Produce.²
• Keter Plastic -> Barkan Industrial Zone -> Costco Hardlines.⁷
• Albaad -> Kirkland Wipes.²

Domain 4: Political & Governance Complicity (V-POL)

Goal: To evaluate the ideological alignment of Costco’s leadership and governance structures with the Israeli state, and to test the consistency of its ethical sourcing policies via the “Safe Harbor” test.

Evidence & Analysis:

1. The “Safe Harbor” Double Standard

The most damning evidence of political complicity is the application of the “Safe Harbor” Test.

• Russia: In February 2022, following the invasion of Ukraine, Costco swiftly suspended operations and purchasing in Russia. This decision was voluntary and exceeded initial sanctions requirements, framed as a moral imperative.²⁸
• Israel: In contrast, following the 2023 onslaught on Gaza and the ICJ ruling on genocide, Costco maintained “Business as Usual.” There was no suspension of purchasing from Israeli vendors, even those in illegal settlements like Keter.
• Conclusion: This divergence proves that Costco’s “ethical sourcing” is not based on universal human rights principles but is politically selective. It activates only when aligned with U.S. State Department directives. Costco operates within the “Safe Harbor” of U.S. imperialism, protecting U.S. allies while sanctioning U.S. adversaries.

2. The Establishment Nexus: Hamilton James & Gina Raimondo

Costco’s governance is effectively captured by the U.S. national security establishment.

• Hamilton E. James (Chairman): His appointment to the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board (PIAB) in 2023 ⁶ places him deep within the U.S. intelligence apparatus. It is structurally impossible for a Chairman with this level of clearance to authorize a boycott of a strategic U.S. ally like Israel. His leadership ensures Costco remains a loyal economic partner to the Zionist state, prioritizing “stability” over human rights.
• Gina Raimondo (Director): Her nomination to the board brings the former Commerce Secretary into the fold. Her record of refusing to pause firearm exports to Israel during the Gaza genocide ¹⁶ signals that Costco’s board is now fortified with political heavyweights committed to maintaining trade flows with Israel regardless of the humanitarian cost.

3. Economic Statecraft: The Smotrich Solicitation

In 2023, Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich explicitly targeted Costco’s leadership (James and Jelinek) with a formal invitation to enter the Israeli market.15

• Significance: Smotrich viewed Costco not just as a retailer, but as a geopolitical asset capable of stabilizing the Israeli economy and lowering the cost of living during a time of crisis. While Costco has not yet opened a store, the fact that it is courted as a savior for the Israeli economy highlights its strategic weight.

4. Internal Suppression: The BLM Precedent

In 2020, Costco faced controversy for banning employees from wearing “Black Lives Matter” masks, categorizing them as “political” attire while allowing other symbols.41

• Relevance: This establishes a precedent of “Neutrality as Suppression.” This policy creates a framework where expressions of Palestine solidarity (e.g., “Ceasefire Now” pins) are banned as “political,” while support for the status quo (e.g., wearing a Star of David or US flag) is normalized. The company uses “neutrality” to silence dissent from its workforce regarding its supply chain complicity.

Analytical Assessment: Moderate-High Confidence. The political complicity is structural and passive-aggressive. It manifests in the refusal to apply equal standards to Israel and the deep integration of the board with the U.S. political establishment that shields Israel.

Named Entities / Evidence Map:

• Hamilton E. James -> President’s Intelligence Advisory Board -> U.S. Strategic Alignment.⁶
• Gina Raimondo -> Commerce Dept. Policies -> Board Nomination.¹⁸
• Safe Harbor Test -> Russia Sanctions vs. Israel Normalization.⁵

5. BDS-1000 Classification

Results Summary:

Final Score: 324

Tier: Tier D (Moderate Complicity)

Justification Summary: Costco falls into Tier D because it functions as a systemic “Gray Zone” logistical node. It extracts massive value from the Israeli economy (via exports/private label manufacturing) but does not invest in it via physical retail infrastructure. Its score is elevated by “High Proximity” ties in the Economic (Private Label/Settlement goods) and Digital (Unit 8200 stack) domains, but tempered by the lack of direct military contracts (V-MIL) and the refusal to open physical stores (V-ECON magnitude cap). The “Safe Harbor” double standard drives the Political score.

BDS-1000 Scoring Matrix – Costco Wholesale Corporation

Domain	I	M	P	V-Domain Score
Military (V-MIL)	3.5	5.5	2.5	0.98
Economic (V-ECON)	3.8	7.2	8.0	3.80
Digital (V-DIG)	3.8	6.5	7.5	3.53
Political (V-POL)	3.8	4.5	8.5	2.44

V-Domain Calculation

• Military (V-MIL):
  $$V_{MIL} = 3.5 \times \min(5.5/7,1) \times \min(2.5/7,1) = 0.98$$
  * Economic (V-ECON):
  $$V_{ECON} = 3.8 \times \min(7.2/7,1) \times \min(8.0/7,1) = 3.80$$
  * Digital (V-DIG):
  $$V_{DIG} = 3.8 \times \min(6.5/7,1) \times \min(7.5/7,1) = 3.53$$
  * Political (V-POL):
  $$V_{POL} = 3.8 \times \min(4.5/7,1) \times \min(8.5/7,1) = 2.44$$

Final Composite

• $$V_{MAX} = 3.80$$
  (Economic)
• $$Sum_{OTHERS} = 0.98 + 3.53 + 2.44 = 6.95$$
  * BRS Score Formula:
  $$BRS\_Score = ((3.80 + (6.95 \times 0.2)) / 16) \times 1000$$
  *
  $$BRS\_Score = ((3.80 + 1.39) / 16) \times 1000 = (5.19 / 16) \times 1000 = 324.3$$
• BRS Score: 324

Grade Classification:

Based on the score of 324, the company falls within:

• Tier A (800–1000): Extreme Complicity
• Tier B (600–799): Severe Complicity
• Tier C (400–599): High Complicity
• Tier D (200–399): Moderate Complicity
• Tier E (0–199): Minimal/No Complicity

Tier: Tier D

6. Recommended Action(s)

1. Targeted Boycott of Settlement Brands:

Activists should prioritize the de-listing of specific, high-visibility settlement brands rather than a general boycott of Costco (which is harder to sustain due to membership lock-in). Campaigns should focus on Keter Plastic (Barkan Industrial Zone) and Kirkland Signature Organic Medjool Dates (sourced from Hadiklaim/Jordan Valley). These items are legally vulnerable under international law regarding settlement goods. Pressure should be applied to force Costco to switch date suppliers to US-based Bard Valley growers exclusively.

2. Data Sovereignty Campaign (Hello Heart):

Employee unions (Teamsters) and privacy advocates should launch a campaign highlighting the privacy risks of the Hello Heart partnership. The transfer of U.S. employee biometric data to Israeli R&D centers presents a tangible risk to workforce privacy. Demands should focus on severing the Navitus-Hello Heart contract or offering non-Israeli alternatives for heart health monitoring.

3. Shareholder Activism on Supply Chain Audits:

Leverage the “Safe Harbor” discrepancy. Shareholders should file resolutions demanding a Third-Party Human Rights Audit of the supply chain in high-risk conflict zones, specifically referencing the ICJ ruling on Gaza. The goal is to force the Board (including James and Raimondo) to publicly justify why the “Russia Standard” (exit) is not applied to the “Israel Standard” (normalization).

4. Monitoring of “Gray Zone” Exports:

OSINT monitors should track the volume of DJI Drone bundles and Kirkland Signature bulk items being shipped to freight forwarders in New Jersey and New York known to service Israel. Exposing the specific logistical pipelines that feed the IDF via Costco would embarrass the leadership and force stricter End-User Monitoring (EUM) controls.

Works cited

1. Costco Calc
2. Costco Economic Audit
3. Costco Digital Audit
4. Hello Heart Partners with Navitus to Empower Plan Members with Best-in-Class Digital Heart Health Solution | Press, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.helloheart.com/press/hello-heart-partners-with-navitus-to-empower-plan-members-with-best-in-class-digital-heart-health-solution
5. Costco Political Audit
6. Hamilton E. James – Grokipedia, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://grokipedia.com/page/Hamilton_E._James
7. Boycott Campaign: Costco – Cloudfront.net, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/cjpme/pages/1019/attachments/original/1455823939/Document1954.pdf?1455823939
8. Jeffrey Brotman – Wikipedia, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_Brotman
9. Jeffrey Brotman – Jewish Virtual Library, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jeffrey-brotman
10. James Sinegal – Wikipedia, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Sinegal
11. Integrity and Values: Interview with Dr. Jim Sinegal, Costco Wholesale Corporation, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://digitalcommons.sacredheart.edu/neje/vol11/iss2/3/
12. Hamilton E. James – Wikipedia, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamilton_E._James
13. Biden Appoints Two New Members to President’s Intelligence Advisory Board – HSToday, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.hstoday.us/subject-matter-areas/intelligence/biden-appoints-two-new-members-to-presidents-intelligence-advisory-board/
14. Costco Military Audit
15. Smotrich invites US giant Costco to enter Israeli market – Globes English – גלובס, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://en.globes.co.il/en/article-smotrich-invites-us-giant-costco-to-enter-israeli-market-1001437304
16. Maryknoll OGC Joins Letter to Secretary Blinken and Secretary Raimondo, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://maryknollogc.org/2024/01/25/maryknoll-ogc-joins-letter-secretary-blinken-and-secretary-raimondo/
17. Letter to Commerce – Arms Export Pause – Joaquin Castro, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://castro.house.gov/imo/media/doc/letter_to_commerce_-_arms_export_pause.pdf
18. Costco Wholesale Corporation Announces Nomination of Gina Raimondo to Board of Directors, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.barchart.com/story/news/36464479/costco-wholesale-corporation-announces-nomination-of-gina-raimondo-to-board-of-directors
19. Costco Wholesale Corporation Announces Nomination of Gina Raimondo to Board of Directors | Markets Insider, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/costco-wholesale-corporation-announces-nomination-of-gina-raimondo-to-board-of-directors-1035620090
20. Costco’s Digital Sales Surge 21% as Members Maintain Spending | PYMNTS.com, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.pymnts.com/news/retail/2025/costcos-digital-sales-surge-21-as-members-maintain-spending/
21. Perrigo Company Completes Acquisition of Agis Industries – Mar 17, 2005, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://investor.perrigo.com/2005-03-17-Perrigo-Company-Completes-Acquisition-of-Agis-Industries
22. Perrigo Company Reports Fiscal Year 2005 Financial Results, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://investor.perrigo.com/2005-09-07-Perrigo-Company-Reports-Fiscal-Year-2005-Financial-Results
23. Ahava Stolen Beauty – followthethings.com, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://followthethings.com/?p=7785
24. Boycott of Ahava Dead Sea products makes an impact – BDS Movement, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://bdsmovement.net/news/boycott-ahava-dead-sea-products-makes-impact
25. Instacart Launches New Prescription Delivery Service with Costco Across Nearly 200 Costco Warehouse Locations – PR Newswire, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/instacart-launches-new-prescription-delivery-service-with-costco-across-nearly-200-costco-warehouse-locations-301042159.html
26. SSM Health Partners with Costco Wholesale Corporation to Expand Affordable Drug Coverage – Navitus, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://navitus.com/press-release/ssm-health-partners-with-costco-wholesale-corporat/
27. Costco buys interest in Navitus – Wisconsin Health News, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://wisconsinhealthnews.com/2020/03/04/costco-buys-interest-in-navitus/
28. #LeaveRussia: Costco is Temporarily Pausing Operations in Russia, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://leave-russia.org/costco
29. Squeezing Putin, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://squeezingputin.com/
30. Israel invites US retail giant Costco to make foray into local food market, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-invites-us-retail-giant-costco-to-make-foray-into-local-food-market/
31. Costco Just Announced Another Major Shopping Change, and It Has Shoppers Divided, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.apartmenttherapy.com/costco-card-scanner-id-37416922
32. DJI fights U.S. government classification as ‘Chinese military company,’ appeals ruling, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://mashable.com/article/dji-drone-chinese-military-company-lawsuit-appeal
33. Ukraine troops downed this DJI Mavic. I’m wondering, what are DJI doing in military affair, raises many questions about data, location tracking, supplies of drones, etc. – Reddit, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/drones/comments/18ggkq6/ukraine_troops_downed_this_dji_mavic_im_wondering/
34. CyberArk Is a Proud Participant in the Microsoft Security Store Partner Ecosystem, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.cyberark.com/press/cyberark-is-a-proud-participant-in-the-microsoft-security-store-partner-ecosystem/
35. Check Point Software Technologies and Wiz Enter Strategic Partnership to Deliver End-to-End Cloud Security, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.checkpoint.com/press-releases/check-point-software-technologies-and-wiz-enter-strategic-partnership-to-deliver-end-to-end-cloud-security/
36. Protecting the Checkout Line | Understanding the Top Threats to Retail Cybersecurity, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.sentinelone.com/blog/protecting-the-checkout-line-understanding-the-top-threats-to-retail-cybersecurity/
37. Companies using Check Point and its marketshare – Enlyft, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://enlyft.com/tech/products/check-point
38. Costco to sell planters made from recycled cartons in collaboration with Tetra Pak & Keter, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://retailtimes.co.uk/costco-to-sell-planters-made-from-recycled-cartons-in-collaboration-with-tetra-pak-keter/
39. Costco: Could Circular Containers Encourage Green Gardening? | Sustainability Magazine, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://sustainabilitymag.com/articles/costco-could-circular-containers-encourage-green-gardening
40. Boycott campaign: Keter plastic – CJPME – English, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.cjpme.org/fs_249
41. Costco penalizes workers for wearing Black Lives Matter masks – Revolt TV, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://www.revolt.tv/article/2020-07-12/73874/costco-penalizes-workers-for-wearing-black-lives-matter-masks
42. Costco employees sent home for wearing BLM masks – TheGrio, accessed on December 13, 2025, https://thegrio.com/2020/07/13/costco-employees-sent-home-blm-masks/